Card Sharon E, Snell Linda, O'Brien Brian
Department of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2006 Nov 17;6:56. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-6-56.
At a time of increased need and demand for general internists in Canada, the attractiveness of generalist careers (including general internal medicine, GIM) has been falling as evidenced by the low number of residents choosing this specialty. One hypothesis for the lack of interest in a generalist career is lack of comfort with the skills needed to practice after training, and the mismatch between the tertiary care, inpatient training environment and "real life". This project was designed to determine perceived effectiveness of training for 10 years of graduates of Canadian GIM programs to assist in the development of curriculum and objectives for general internists that will meet the needs of graduates and ultimately society.
Mailed survey designed to explore perceived importance of training for and preparation for various aspects of Canadian GIM practice. After extensive piloting of the survey, including a pilot survey of two universities to improve the questionnaire, all graduates of the 16 universities over the previous ten years were surveyed.
Gaps (difference between importance and preparation) were demonstrated in many of the CanMEDS 2000/2005 competencies. Medical problems of pregnancy, perioperative care, pain management, chronic care, ambulatory care and community GIM rotations were the medical expert areas with the largest gaps. Exposure to procedural skills was perceived to be lacking. Some procedural skills valued as important for current GIM trainees and performed frequently (example ambulatory ECG interpretation) had low preparation ratings by trainees. Other areas of perceived discrepancy between training and practice included: manager role (set up of an office), health advocate (counseling for prevention, for example smoking cessation), and professional (end of life issues, ethics).
Graduates of Canadian GIM training programs over the last ten years have identified perceived gaps between training and important areas for practice. They have identified competencies that should be emphasized in Canadian GIM programs. Ongoing review of graduate's perceptions of training programs as it applies to their current practice is important to ensure ongoing appropriateness of training programs. This information will be used to strengthen GIM training programs in Canada.
在加拿大对普通内科医生的需求不断增加之际,全科医生职业(包括普通内科,GIM)的吸引力却在下降,选择该专业的住院医师人数较少就证明了这一点。对全科医生职业缺乏兴趣的一个假设是,对培训后执业所需技能缺乏信心,以及三级医疗、住院培训环境与“现实生活”之间的不匹配。本项目旨在确定加拿大GIM项目十年毕业生对培训效果的认知,以协助制定满足毕业生及最终社会需求的普通内科医生课程和目标。
通过邮寄调查问卷,探讨对加拿大GIM实践各个方面培训的认知重要性和准备情况。在对调查问卷进行广泛试点,包括对两所大学进行试点调查以改进问卷后,对过去十年16所大学的所有毕业生进行了调查。
在许多2000/2005年加拿大医学教育目标(CanMEDS)能力方面存在差距(重要性与准备情况之间的差异)。妊娠医学问题、围手术期护理、疼痛管理、慢性病护理、门诊护理和社区GIM轮转是差距最大的医学专家领域。人们认为在程序技能方面的接触不足。一些对当前GIM实习生很重要且经常执行的程序技能(如门诊心电图解读),实习生的准备评级较低。培训与实践之间存在认知差异的其他领域包括:管理者角色(办公室设置)、健康倡导者(预防咨询,如戒烟)和专业人员(临终问题、伦理)。
过去十年加拿大GIM培训项目的毕业生已经确定了培训与重要实践领域之间的认知差距。他们确定了加拿大GIM项目应强调的能力。持续审查毕业生对培训项目与当前实践适用性的认知,对于确保培训项目持续合适至关重要。这些信息将用于加强加拿大的GIM培训项目。