Patthoff Donald E
J Dent Educ. 2006 Nov;70(11):1125-32.
This article reviews the history and future good of acceptance ethics and helps frame the publication of papers presented at the workshop on Professional Promises: Hopes and Gaps in Access to Oral Health Care. Discovery and development of Universal Patient Acceptance (UPA), a practical application of acceptance ethics, is key to systematizing access to oral health; UPA expands partnerships among professional volunteerism, culture, and economic structures. A Veterans' Administration health services preventive dentistry research project and a West Virginia school children's preventive dental program raised awareness of acceptance. A state insurance crisis revealed an underlying systems ethics problem that was not purely legal, political, educational, economic, or scientific in nature. Key players were identified for dialogue, and questions were ranked. UPA was articulated and proposed as a unique, practical, and positive professional promise. The experience involved PEDNET, a dental ethics education group. An intensive applied dental ethics course for practicing dentists was developed; it attracted the American College of Dentists (ACD) and American Dental Association (ADA). Annual ACD LeaderSkills helped expand continuing education of ethics; several dental ethics summits were initiated. Concepts like discourse, adequate care, and viewing organizations as both persons and machines motivated further exploration of acceptance. Separating acceptance from diagnosis, treatment, and payment improves discourse on the various philosophical notions and practical applications that dominate each area.
本文回顾了接纳伦理学的历史及未来前景,并为在“专业承诺:口腔医疗服务获取中的希望与差距”研讨会上发表的论文提供了框架。通用患者接纳(UPA)作为接纳伦理学的一种实际应用,其发现与发展是使口腔医疗服务获取系统化的关键;UPA拓展了专业志愿服务、文化和经济结构之间的伙伴关系。一项退伍军人管理局医疗服务预防性牙科研究项目以及西弗吉尼亚州学童预防性牙科项目提高了人们对接纳的认识。一场州保险危机揭示了一个潜在的系统伦理学问题,该问题本质上并非纯粹的法律、政治、教育、经济或科学问题。确定了关键参与者进行对话,并对问题进行了排序。UPA得以阐述并被提议作为一项独特、实用且积极的专业承诺。该经历涉及牙科伦理学教育组织PEDNET。为执业牙医开发了一门强化应用牙科伦理学课程;该课程吸引了美国牙医学会(ACD)和美国牙科协会(ADA)。ACD年度领导力技能培训有助于扩大伦理学继续教育;发起了数次牙科伦理学峰会。诸如话语、充分护理以及将组织视为人和机器等概念促使人们对接纳进行进一步探索。将接纳与诊断、治疗和支付区分开来,有助于就主导每个领域的各种哲学概念和实际应用展开讨论。