McDonnell Peter J, Kirwan Thomas J, Brinton Gregory S, Golnik Karl C, Melendez Robert F, Parke David W, Renucci Ann, Smith Jennifer Hasenyager, Smith Ronald E
Wilmer Ophthalmological Institute, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland 21287-9278, USA.
Ophthalmology. 2007 Feb;114(2):387-91. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2006.10.027. Epub 2006 Dec 20.
To evaluate young ophthalmologists' perceptions of how well residency training prepared them for various aspects of their clinical practice.
Self-administered survey.
Two hundred sixty-nine United States ophthalmologists who have been in practice for < or =5 years.
A 4-page questionnaire was mailed to a randomly selected sample of 900 U.S. members and fellows of the American Academy of Ophthalmology who had been in practice for < or =5 years.
Comparison of perceived preparedness in clinical and nonclinical areas of ophthalmology practice.
Two hundred sixty-nine surveys were completed and returned (margin of error, +/-5%). Analysis of tabulated results indicated that 86% said they were extremely or very well prepared to practice comprehensive ophthalmology after residency training. Even so, about half of those respondents also desired some additional clinical training, and two thirds felt the need for some additional training in surgical areas (refractive, oculoplastics/orbital, glaucoma, retina, and pediatric ophthalmic surgery). At least 60% reported being not very or not at all well prepared in 6 of the nonclinical areas explored (business operations and finance, personal financial management, practice management skills, coding and reimbursement, political advocacy, and exposure to practice setting models). With the exception of personal financial management, most ophthalmologists thought training in all of these nonclinical areas was the responsibility of the residency training program.
The transition from residency training to successful, efficient, ethical, high-quality ophthalmic practice demands a number of skills in addition to diagnostic acumen and surgical ability. In general, the U.S. residency program graduates surveyed are comfortable with their clinical training, but less so with their training in nonclinical areas. Opportunities to help ophthalmologists prepare better for the transition to clinical practice after training appear to exist and might be addressed by training programs, professional organizations, informal physician networks, and other stakeholders.
评估年轻眼科医生对住院医师培训在临床实践各方面准备程度的看法。
自行管理的调查。
269名从业年限≤5年的美国眼科医生。
向900名随机抽取的美国眼科学会会员及研究员(从业年限≤5年)邮寄一份4页的问卷。
眼科临床和非临床领域感知准备程度的比较。
共完成并回收269份调查问卷(误差幅度为±5%)。对统计结果的分析表明,86%的人表示住院医师培训后他们为从事综合眼科实践做好了极其充分或非常充分的准备。即便如此,约一半的受访者仍希望获得一些额外的临床培训,三分之二的人认为需要在手术领域(屈光、眼整形/眼眶、青光眼、视网膜和小儿眼科手术)接受一些额外培训。在探索的6个非临床领域(业务运营与财务、个人财务管理、实践管理技能、编码与报销、政治宣传以及对实践模式的接触)中,至少60%的人表示准备不太充分或根本不充分。除个人财务管理外,大多数眼科医生认为所有这些非临床领域的培训应由住院医师培训项目负责。
从住院医师培训向成功、高效、合乎道德且高质量的眼科实践过渡,除了诊断敏锐度和手术能力外,还需要许多技能。总体而言,接受调查的美国住院医师培训项目毕业生对其临床培训感到满意,但对非临床领域的培训满意度较低。似乎存在帮助眼科医生在培训后更好地为向临床实践过渡做准备的机会,培训项目、专业组织、非正式医生网络及其他利益相关者或许可以解决这些问题。