Novack L, Jotkowitz A, Knyazer B, Novack V
Department of Epidemiology and Health Services Evaluation, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University in the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel.
Postgrad Med J. 2006 Dec;82(974):817-22. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.2006.049262.
An understanding of statistical methods and basic epidemiology are crucial for the practice of modern medicine.
To assess (1) the knowledge of basic methods of conducting research and data analysis among residents and practicing doctors and (2) the effect of country of medical school graduation, professional status, medical article reading and writing experience on the level of this knowledge.
Data were collected by means of a supervised self-administered questionnaire, which was distributed among doctors at Soroka Medical Center, Beer-Sheva, Israel. The questionnaire included 10 multiple-choice questions on basic epidemiology and statistics, and respondent demographical data.
Of the 260 eligible doctors, 219 (84.2%) returned completed questionnaires. Of the 219 doctors, 50% graduated more than 8.5 years ago, 39.7% were specialists and the remaining were residents. The most frequent specialty was internal medicine (37.4%). Israel was the most frequent country of graduation (45.7%), followed by the former Soviet Union (Eastern medical education; 38.4%). The median total score of knowledge was 4 of 10 questions (interquartile range 2-6). A higher score was associated with a Western medical education, being a specialist, shorter elapsed time since graduation, higher number of publications and self-reported reading of "methods" and "discussion" sections in scientific articles.
This study found a low level of knowledge of basic principles of research methods and data analysis among doctors, and this knowledge considerably differed by country of medical school graduation.
了解统计方法和基础流行病学对现代医学实践至关重要。
评估(1)住院医师和执业医生对开展研究及数据分析基本方法的知识掌握情况,以及(2)医学院校毕业国家、专业地位、医学文章阅读和写作经历对该知识水平的影响。
通过一份在监督下自行填写的问卷收集数据,该问卷分发给以色列贝尔谢巴索罗卡医疗中心的医生。问卷包括10道关于基础流行病学和统计学的多项选择题以及受访者的人口统计学数据。
在260名符合条件的医生中,219名(84.2%)返回了完整问卷。在这219名医生中,50%于8.5年多以前毕业,39.7%是专科医生,其余是住院医师。最常见的专业是内科(37.4%)。毕业国家最常见的是以色列(45.7%),其次是前苏联(东欧医学教育;38.4%)。知识总得分中位数是10道题中的4分(四分位间距为2 - 6)。得分较高与接受西方医学教育、身为专科医生、毕业时间较短、发表文章数量较多以及自我报告阅读科学文章的“方法”和“讨论”部分有关。
本研究发现医生对研究方法和数据分析基本原则的知识掌握水平较低,且这种知识因医学院校毕业国家的不同而有很大差异。