Witte Irene, Plappert Ulla, de Wall Hartmut, Hartmann Andreas
Institute for Biology and Environmental Sciences, University of Oldenburg, Germany.
Toxicol Sci. 2007 May;97(1):21-6. doi: 10.1093/toxsci/kfl192. Epub 2007 Jan 4.
Early screening of drug candidates for genotoxicity typically includes an analysis for mutagenicity in bacteria and for clastogenicity in cultured mammalian cells. In addition, in recent years, an early assessment of photogenotoxicity potential has become increasingly important. Also, for screening purposes, expert computer systems can be used to identify structural alerts. In cases where structural alerts are identified, mutagenicity testing limited to bacteria can be conducted. The sequence of computer-aided analysis and limited testing using bacteria allows for screening a comparatively large number of drug candidates. In contrast, considerably more resources, in terms of supplies, technical time, and the amount of a test substance needed, are required when screening for clastogenic activity in mammalian cells. In addition, the relatively large percentage of false positive results for rodent carcinogenicity associated with clastogenicity assays is of considerable concern. As a consequence, mammalian cell-based alternatives to clastogenicity assays are needed for early screening of mammalian genotoxicity. The comet assay is a relatively fast, simple, and sensitive technique for the analysis of DNA damage in mammalian cells. This assay seems especially useful for screening purposes because false positives associated with excessive toxicity appear to occur less frequently, only relatively small amounts of a test compound are needed, and certain steps of the test procedure can be automated. Therefore, the in vitro comet assay is proposed as an alternative to cytogenetic assays in early genotoxicity/photogenotoxicity screening of drug candidates.
药物候选物遗传毒性的早期筛查通常包括细菌致突变性分析和培养的哺乳动物细胞染色体断裂分析。此外,近年来,光遗传毒性潜力的早期评估变得越来越重要。而且,为了筛查目的,可以使用专家计算机系统来识别结构警示。在识别出结构警示的情况下,可以进行仅限于细菌的致突变性测试。计算机辅助分析和使用细菌进行有限测试的顺序允许筛选相对大量的药物候选物。相比之下,在筛选哺乳动物细胞中的染色体断裂活性时,在耗材、技术时间和所需测试物质的量方面需要更多的资源。此外,与染色体断裂分析相关的啮齿动物致癌性假阳性结果的相对高比例令人相当担忧。因此,早期筛选哺乳动物遗传毒性需要基于哺乳动物细胞的染色体断裂分析替代方法。彗星试验是一种用于分析哺乳动物细胞DNA损伤的相对快速、简单且灵敏的技术。该试验对于筛查目的似乎特别有用,因为与过度毒性相关的假阳性似乎较少发生,只需要相对少量的测试化合物,并且测试程序的某些步骤可以自动化。因此,体外彗星试验被提议作为药物候选物早期遗传毒性/光遗传毒性筛查中细胞遗传学试验的替代方法。