Pohl M, Werner C, Holzgraefe M, Kroczek G, Mehrholz J, Wingendorf I, Hoölig G, Koch R, Hesse S
Klinik Bavaria, Neurological Rehabilitation, Kreischa, Germany.
Clin Rehabil. 2007 Jan;21(1):17-27. doi: 10.1177/0269215506071281.
To evaluate the effect of repetitive locomotor training on an electromechanical gait trainer plus physiotherapy in subacute stroke patients.
Randomized controlled trial.
Four German neurological rehabilitation centres.
One hundred and fifty-five non-ambulatory patients (first-time stroke <60 days).
Group A received 20 min locomotor training and 25 min physiotherapy; group B had 45 min physiotherapy every week day for four weeks.
Primary variables were gait ability (Functional Ambulation Category, 0-5) and the Barthel Index (0-100), blindly assessed at study onset, end, and six months later for follow-up. Responders to the therapy had to become ambulatory (Functional Ambulation Category 4 or 5) or reach a Barthel Index of > or = 75. Secondary variables were walking velocity, endurance, mobility and leg power.
The intention-to-treat analysis revealed that significantly greater number of patients in group A could walk independently: 41 of 77 versus 17 of 78 in group B (P B < 0.0001) at treatment end. Also, significantly more group A patients had reached a Barthel Index > or = 75: 44 of 77 versus 21 of 78 (P B < 0.0001). At six-month follow-up, the superior gait ability in group A persisted (54 of 77 versus 28 of 78, P B < 0.0001), while the Barthel Index responder rate did not differ. For all secondary variables, group A patients had improved significantly more (P B < 0.0001) during the treatment period, but not during follow-up.
Intensive locomotor training plus physiotherapy resulted in a significantly better gait ability and daily living competence in subacute stroke patients compared with physiotherapy alone.
评估重复性运动训练对亚急性卒中患者使用机电步态训练器结合物理治疗的效果。
随机对照试验。
四个德国神经康复中心。
155例非步行患者(首次卒中<60天)。
A组接受20分钟运动训练和25分钟物理治疗;B组在四个工作日中每天接受45分钟物理治疗,共四周。
主要变量为步态能力(功能性步行分类,0 - 5级)和巴氏指数(0 - 100),在研究开始、结束时以及六个月后的随访时进行盲法评估。治疗有反应者必须能够独立行走(功能性步行分类4级或5级)或巴氏指数达到≥75。次要变量为步行速度、耐力、活动能力和腿部力量。
意向性分析显示,治疗结束时,A组能够独立行走的患者数量显著多于B组:A组77例中有41例,B组78例中有17例(PB<0.0001)。此外,A组中达到巴氏指数≥75的患者也显著更多:A组77例中有44例,B组78例中有21例(PB<0.0001)。在六个月的随访中,A组优越的步态能力持续存在(A组77例中有54例,B组78例中有28例,PB<0.0001),而巴氏指数有反应者的比例没有差异。对于所有次要变量,A组患者在治疗期间改善更为显著(PB<0.0001),但在随访期间没有差异。
与单纯物理治疗相比,强化运动训练加物理治疗能使亚急性卒中患者的步态能力和日常生活能力显著改善。