Sebo Paul, Bouvier Gallacchi Martine, Goehring Catherine, Künzi Beat, Bovier Patrick A
Department of community and primary care medicine, University Hospitals of Geneva, Switzerland.
BMC Public Health. 2007 Jan 12;7:5. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-7-5.
Health behaviours among doctors has been suggested to be an important marker of how harmful lifestyle behaviours are perceived. In several countries, decrease in smoking among physicians was spectacular, indicating that the hazard was well known. Historical data have shown that because of their higher socio-economical status physicians take up smoking earlier. When the dangers of smoking become better known, physicians began to give up smoking at a higher rate than the general population. For alcohol consumption, the situation is quite different: prevalence is still very high among physicians and the dangers are not so well perceived. To study the situation in Switzerland, data of a national survey were analysed to determine the prevalence of smoking and alcohol drinking among primary care physicians.
2,756 randomly selected practitioners were surveyed to assess subjective mental and physical health and their determinants, including smoking and drinking behaviours. Physicians were categorised as never smokers, current smokers and former smokers, as well as non drinkers, drinkers (AUDIT-C < 4 for women and < 5 for men) and at risk drinkers (higher scores).
1'784 physicians (65%) responded (men 84%, mean age 51 years). Twelve percent were current smokers and 22% former smokers. Sixty six percent were drinkers and 30% at risk drinkers. Only 4% were never smokers and non drinkers. Forty eight percent of current smokers were also at risk drinkers and 16% of at risk drinkers were also current smokers. Smoking and at risk drinking were more frequent among men, middle aged physicians and physicians living alone. When compared to a random sample of the Swiss population, primary care physicians were two to three times less likely to be active smokers (12% vs. 30%), but were more likely to be drinkers (96% vs. 78%), and twice more likely to be at risk drinkers (30% vs. 15%).
The prevalence of current smokers among Swiss primary care physicians was much lower than in the general population in Switzerland, reflecting that the hazards of smoking are well known to doctors. However, the opposite was found for alcohol use, underlining the importance of making efforts in this area to increase awareness among physicians of the dangers of alcohol consumption.
医生的健康行为被认为是有害生活方式行为认知程度的重要标志。在一些国家,医生吸烟率的下降非常显著,这表明吸烟的危害已广为人知。历史数据显示,由于医生较高的社会经济地位,他们更早开始吸烟。当吸烟的危害被更多人了解后,医生戒烟的比例开始高于普通人群。对于饮酒而言,情况则大不相同:医生中的饮酒率仍然很高,且对饮酒危害的认知不足。为研究瑞士的情况,我们分析了一项全国性调查的数据,以确定初级保健医生的吸烟和饮酒率。
随机选取2756名从业者进行调查,以评估他们的主观身心健康状况及其影响因素,包括吸烟和饮酒行为。医生被分为从不吸烟者、当前吸烟者和曾经吸烟者,以及不饮酒者、饮酒者(女性酒精使用障碍筛查测试-C评分<4,男性<5)和有饮酒风险者(评分更高)。
1784名医生(65%)回复了调查(男性占84%,平均年龄51岁)。12%为当前吸烟者,22%为曾经吸烟者。66%为饮酒者,30%为有饮酒风险者。只有4%从不吸烟且不饮酒。48%的当前吸烟者同时也是有饮酒风险者,16%的有饮酒风险者同时也是当前吸烟者。吸烟和有饮酒风险的情况在男性、中年医生和独居医生中更为常见。与瑞士普通人群的随机样本相比,初级保健医生成为现吸烟者的可能性要低两到三倍(12%对30%),但饮酒的可能性更高(96%对78%),有饮酒风险的可能性则高出一倍(30%对15%)。
瑞士初级保健医生中现吸烟者的比例远低于瑞士普通人群,这反映出医生对吸烟危害的认知程度较高。然而,饮酒情况则相反,这凸显了在这一领域努力提高医生对饮酒危害认识的重要性。