Torley H I, Madhok R, Capell H A, Brouwer R M, Maddison P J, Black C M, Englert H, Dormandy J A, Watson H R
Royal Infirmary, Glasgow.
Ann Rheum Dis. 1991 Nov;50(11):800-4. doi: 10.1136/ard.50.11.800.
To compare low (0.5 ng/kg/min) and standard dose (2 ng/kg/min) iloprost (a stable carbacyclin analogue of prostacyclin) in patients with Raynaud's phenomenon secondary to connective tissue disorders.
Double blind, random allocation, three six hour infusions on consecutive days. Follow up period eight weeks.
Rheumatology units, five teaching hospitals.
55 Patients with Raynaud's phenomenon (greater than seven attacks per week), 32 secondary to well documented classical progressive systemic sclerosis (American Rheumatism Association criteria), 11 CREST syndrome, 5 mixed connective tissue disease, 1 rheumatoid arthritis, 1 Sjögren's syndrome, 1 childhood dermatomyositis, and 4 abnormal nailfold capillaroscopy and antibody profiles but no definite diagnosis.
All other treatment for Raynaud's phenomenon was discontinued two weeks before entry. 28 Patients were randomly allocated to receive the low dose, 27 the standard dose. Differing dilutions allowed infusion rates to be started at 10 ml/h with increments of 10 ml/h every 15 minutes until infusion rates reached 0.5 ng/kg/min and 2 ng/kg/min respectively. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(s)--Reduction in frequency, duration, and severity of attacks of Raynaud's phenomenon. Assessment of ulcer and ischaemic lesion healing.
Both dosage regimens were equally effective in reducing severity, frequency, and duration of Raynaud's attacks. Ulcer healing occurred to similar degree in both treatment groups (standard dose 44%, low dose 39%). Low dose was associated with significantly fewer side effects.
Both dosage regimens reduce severity of Raynaud's phenomenon and encourage ulcer healing. Low dose was associated with fewer side effects and was better tolerated by the patients.
比较低剂量(0.5纳克/千克/分钟)和标准剂量(2纳克/千克/分钟)的伊洛前列素(一种稳定的前列环素类似物)在结缔组织病继发雷诺现象患者中的疗效。
双盲、随机分配,连续三天进行三次六小时输注。随访期为八周。
五家教学医院的风湿病科。
55例雷诺现象患者(每周发作超过7次),其中32例继发于有充分记录的经典进行性系统性硬化症(美国风湿病协会标准),11例为CREST综合征,5例为混合性结缔组织病,1例为类风湿关节炎,1例为干燥综合征,1例为儿童皮肌炎,4例甲襞毛细血管镜检查和抗体谱异常但未明确诊断。
入组前两周停用所有其他治疗雷诺现象的药物。28例患者随机分配接受低剂量治疗,27例接受标准剂量治疗。不同的稀释度使输注速度从10毫升/小时开始,每15分钟增加10毫升/小时,直至输注速度分别达到0.5纳克/千克/分钟和2纳克/千克/分钟。主要观察指标——雷诺现象发作频率、持续时间和严重程度的降低。评估溃疡和缺血性病变的愈合情况。
两种剂量方案在降低雷诺发作的严重程度、频率和持续时间方面同样有效。两个治疗组溃疡愈合程度相似(标准剂量组44%,低剂量组39%)。低剂量组副作用明显较少。
两种剂量方案均能降低雷诺现象的严重程度并促进溃疡愈合。低剂量组副作用较少,患者耐受性更好。