Komiyama Osamu, Kawara Misao, De Laat Antoon
Department of Clinical Oral Physiology, Nihon University School of Dentistry at Matsudo, Sakaecho-nishi Matsudo, Chiba, Japan.
J Pain. 2007 Apr;8(4):363-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jpain.2006.12.002. Epub 2007 Feb 1.
The aim of the present study was to evaluate ethnic differences of the tactile detection threshold (TDT), the filament-prick pain detection threshold (FPT), the pressure pain detection threshold (PPT), and the pressure pain tolerance detection threshold (PTOL) in the orofacial region of symptom-free subjects. Twenty-two men and 22 women in Belgium and in Japan (age range from 20 to 31 years) participated. The TDT and the FPT were measured on the cheek skin (CS) overlying the masseter muscles (MM), on the maxillary gingiva (MG), and at the tip of the tongue (TT), using Semmes-Weinstein monofilaments. The PPT and PTOL were measured at the central part of the MM, using a pressure algometer. A general linear model was used in each case to capture ethnic and gender effects. Japanese women had the lowest TDT at CS, in contrast to Belgian men, who had the highest value; a significant ethnic and gender effect was found (P=.026 and P<.001, respectively). Similar results were found for FPT at CS with significant ethnic and gender effects (P<.001 for both). There was no significant ethnic effect regarding intra-oral TDT and FPT or regarding PPT and PTOL.
Our findings clearly indicate that future studies of tactile and pain measurements need to standardize and control for gender and ethnicity. Further, a comprehensive evaluation of results from various stimulation modalities may better clarify the pain mechanisms and gender/ethnic characteristics, as well as comparisons between normal subjects and patients.
本研究的目的是评估无症状受试者口面部区域触觉检测阈值(TDT)、单丝刺痛疼痛检测阈值(FPT)、压力疼痛检测阈值(PPT)和压力疼痛耐受检测阈值(PTOL)的种族差异。比利时和日本的22名男性和22名女性(年龄范围为20至31岁)参与了研究。使用Semmes-Weinstein单丝在上颌咬肌(MM)上方的脸颊皮肤(CS)、上颌牙龈(MG)和舌尖(TT)测量TDT和FPT。使用压力痛觉计在MM的中央部分测量PPT和PTOL。每种情况下均使用一般线性模型来捕捉种族和性别效应。与比利时男性(其值最高)相比,日本女性在CS处的TDT最低;发现了显著的种族和性别效应(分别为P = 0.026和P < 0.001)。在CS处的FPT也发现了类似结果,具有显著的种族和性别效应(两者均为P < 0.001)。关于口腔内TDT和FPT或PPT和PTOL,未发现显著的种族效应。
我们的研究结果清楚地表明,未来关于触觉和疼痛测量的研究需要对性别和种族进行标准化和控制。此外,对各种刺激方式的结果进行综合评估可能会更好地阐明疼痛机制以及性别/种族特征,以及正常受试者与患者之间的比较。