Fukuda Ken-Ichi, Hayashida Masakazu, Fukunaga Atsuo, Kasahara Masataka, Koukita Yoshihiko, Ichinohe Tatsuya, Kaneko Yuzuru
Department of Dental Anesthesia and Orofacial Pain Center, Tokyo Dental College, Suidoubashi Hospital, 2-9-18 Misaki-cho, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, 101-0061, Japan.
J Anesth. 2007;21(1):24-30. doi: 10.1007/s00540-006-0444-3. Epub 2007 Jan 30.
Chronic orofacial pain is often refractory to conventional pain therapies. We conducted an open-label study to determine whether adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) could alleviate chronic intractable orofacial pain, and if so, which type of pain could respond to ATP.
In 8 and 16 patients with non-neuropathic and neuropathic intractable orofacial pain, respectively, ATP was intravenously infused at a rate of 100 microgxkg(-1)xmin(-1) over 120 min. The magnitudes of spontaneous pain and brush-evoked allodynia were graded with a visual analog scale (VAS). When a VAS score for spontaneous pain was decreased by 50% or more by ATP, the patient was classified as a responder.
The patients could be clearly divided into 10 responders and 14 non-responders. Ten of the 16 patients (62.5%) with neuropathic pain, but none of the 8 patients with non-neuropathic pain, responded to ATP. In particular, all of 8 patients with neuropathic pain following pulpectomy, with or without subsequent tooth extraction, responded to ATP. In the 10 responders, VAS scores for spontaneous pain decreased slowly but progressively during the infusion period, and eventually, ATP reduced the VAS scores for spontaneous pain and allodynia by 82 +/- 15% and 74 +/- 9%, respectively. In these responders, the analgesic and anti-allodynic effects of ATP outlasted the infusion period for medians of 7 and 12 h, respectively.
Intravenous ATP did not relieve non-neuropathic orofacial pain. However, it exerted slowly expressed but long-lasting analgesic and anti-allodynic effects in patients with neuropathic orofacial pain, especially in those suffering from neuropathic pain following pulpectomy and/or tooth extraction.
慢性口面部疼痛通常对传统疼痛治疗方法难以奏效。我们开展了一项开放标签研究,以确定5'-三磷酸腺苷(ATP)是否能缓解慢性顽固性口面部疼痛,若能缓解,哪种类型的疼痛对ATP有反应。
分别对8例非神经性顽固性口面部疼痛患者和16例神经性顽固性口面部疼痛患者,以100μg·kg⁻¹·min⁻¹的速率静脉输注ATP,持续120分钟。采用视觉模拟评分法(VAS)对自发痛和刷诱发痛觉过敏的程度进行分级。当ATP使自发痛的VAS评分降低50%或更多时,该患者被归类为反应者。
患者可明显分为10例反应者和14例非反应者。16例神经性疼痛患者中有10例(62.5%)对ATP有反应,但8例非神经性疼痛患者均无反应。特别是,8例牙髓摘除术后无论有无后续拔牙的神经性疼痛患者均对ATP有反应。在10例反应者中,自发痛的VAS评分在输注期间缓慢但逐渐下降,最终,ATP使自发痛和痛觉过敏的VAS评分分别降低了82±15%和74±9%。在这些反应者中,ATP的镇痛和抗痛觉过敏作用分别在输注期结束后持续了7小时和12小时的中位数时间。
静脉注射ATP不能缓解非神经性口面部疼痛。然而,它对神经性口面部疼痛患者,尤其是那些牙髓摘除术和/或拔牙后患有神经性疼痛的患者,具有缓慢起效但持久的镇痛和抗痛觉过敏作用。