Jansen J, Sjaastad O
Department of Neurosurgery, Georg-August Universität, Göttingen, Germany.
Acta Neurol Scand. 2007 Mar;115(3):185-91. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0404.2006.00771.x.
To evaluate the postoperative fate of chronic, hard-to-treat and partly suicidal cervicogenic headache (CEH) patients (n = 32), diagnosed according to the CHISG criteria and treated with a decompression/stabilization operation in the cervical spine: the Smith/Robinson operation.
The cervical levels of affection, singled out by magnetic resonance, anaesthetic blockades and X-ray examinations were mainly at the C4-5, C5-6, C6-7 levels; one or two discs were removed. The study was prospective and controlled.
During the 1- to 3-month-long postoperative period of collar-wearing, there generally was pain freedom. The mean time of follow-up was 19.8 months: pain recurrence, known to the authors, appeared after 1-58 months (n = 12). The mean time of improvement was: 14.8 months (range 1-58 months). Five patients stayed well > or =3 years. This is certainly a minimum figure. The patients ultimately were lost to follow-up.
For the time being, this operation should preferably be used in selected, chronic, severely afflicted, preferably elderly CEH patients, when other therapeutic approaches are exhausted.
评估32例慢性、难治性且部分有自杀倾向的颈源性头痛(CEH)患者术后的转归情况。这些患者根据颈源性头痛国际研究组(CHISG)标准确诊,并接受了颈椎减压/稳定手术:即史密斯/罗宾逊手术。
通过磁共振成像、麻醉阻滞和X线检查确定的受累颈椎节段主要在C4-5、C5-6、C6-7节段;切除了一或两个椎间盘。本研究为前瞻性对照研究。
在术后佩戴颈托的1至3个月期间,患者普遍不再疼痛。平均随访时间为19.8个月:作者已知的疼痛复发发生在1至58个月后(n = 12)。改善的平均时间为:14.8个月(范围1至58个月)。5例患者病情稳定≥3年。这肯定是个最低数字。这些患者最终失访。
目前,当其他治疗方法均无效时,该手术最好用于经过挑选的慢性、病情严重的CEH患者,最好是老年患者。