Molander A, Caplan D, Bergenholtz G, Reit C
Public Dental Service, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Int Endod J. 2007 Apr;40(4):254-60. doi: 10.1111/j.0143-2885.2007.01208.x. Epub 2007 Feb 8.
To test the hypothesis that an increased utilization of nickel-titanium rotary instrumentation (NTRI) by general dental practitioners will lead to an increased frequency of good quality root fillings. A second aim was to determine whether the educational format would exert influence on the quality.
Dentists were assigned at random to three intervention groups: a 4-h lecture (L-group, n = 40); a 4-h lecture plus a full day hands-on course (LH-group, n = 40); or a control group receiving no instruction (n = 68). The control group received education later on in the study. Radiographs of two root filled molar teeth per dentist were selected at random before the start of the education program and after a 6-month clinical learning period. Using length, seal and shape of root-fillings a 5-level variable was created.
The rate of good quality root fillings increased after the introduction of NTRI. Calculated over all types of roots the frequency of excellent (score 1) root fillings increased from 31% to 51% (P = 0.006) in the L-group and from 27% to 47% (P = 0.016) in the LH-group. The frequency of low quality root-fillings (score 5) dropped in the L-group from 22% to 16% (P = 0.29) and in the LH-group from 13% to 9% (P = 0.48). No statistically significant difference was seen among the controls.
When NTRI technology replaced manual stainless steel techniques the rate of good quality root fillings increased. A significant drop in the rate of low quality root fillings was not found.
检验如下假设,即普通牙科医生增加镍钛旋转器械(NTRI)的使用将导致高质量根管充填频率增加。第二个目的是确定教育形式是否会对质量产生影响。
将牙医随机分为三个干预组:4小时讲座组(L组,n = 40);4小时讲座加一整天实践课程组(LH组,n = 40);或不接受指导的对照组(n = 68)。对照组在研究后期接受教育。在教育项目开始前和6个月临床学习期后,为每位牙医随机选取两颗已进行根管充填的磨牙的X光片。根据根管充填的长度、封闭情况和形状创建了一个5级变量。
引入NTRI后,高质量根管充填率增加。计算所有类型的牙根,L组优秀(1分)根管充填的频率从31%增至51%(P = 0.006),LH组从27%增至47%(P = 0.016)。低质量根管充填(5分)的频率在L组从22%降至16%(P = 0.29),在LH组从13%降至9%(P = 0.48)。对照组之间未观察到统计学上的显著差异。
当NTRI技术取代手动不锈钢技术时,高质量根管充填率增加。未发现低质量根管充填率有显著下降。