Fogelson D L, Nuechterlein K H, Asarnow R A, Payne D L, Subotnik K L, Jacobson K C, Neale M C, Kendler K S
Department of Psychiatry and Biobehavioral Sciences, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA, USA.
Schizophr Res. 2007 Mar;91(1-3):192-9. doi: 10.1016/j.schres.2006.12.023. Epub 2007 Feb 15.
It is unresolved whether avoidant personality disorder (APD) is an independent schizophrenia (Sz)-spectrum personality disorder (PD). Some studies find APD and social anxiety symptoms (Sxs) to be separable dimensions of psychopathology in relatives (Rels) of schizophrenics while other studies find avoidant Sxs to be correlated with schizotypal and paranoid Sxs. Rates of APD among first-degree Rels of Sz probands, attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) probands, and community control (CC) probands were examined. Further analyses examined rates when controlling for the presence of schizotypal (SPD) and paranoid (PPD) personality disorders, differences in APD Sxs between relative groups, and whether APD in Rels of Szs reflects a near miss for another Sz-spectrum PD. Three hundred sixty-two first-degree Rels of Sz probands, 201 relatives of ADHD probands, and 245 Rels of CC probands were interviewed for the presence of DSM-III-R Axis I and II disorders. Diagnoses, integrating family history, interview information, and medical records, were determined. APD occurred more frequently in Rels of Sz probands compared to CC probands (p<0.001) and also when controlling for SPD and PPD (p<0.005). Two Sxs of APD were most characteristic of the Rels of Sz probands: "avoids social or occupational activities..." and "exaggerates the potential difficulties..." 65% of the Rels of Sz probands who had diagnoses of APD were more than one criterion short of a DSM-III-R diagnosis of either SPD or PPD. This indicates that APD is a separate Sz-spectrum disorder, and not merely a sub-clinical form of SPD or PPD.
回避型人格障碍(APD)是否为一种独立的精神分裂症(Sz)谱系人格障碍(PD)尚未明确。一些研究发现,在精神分裂症患者的亲属(Rels)中,APD和社交焦虑症状(Sxs)是精神病理学的可分离维度,而其他研究发现回避型症状与分裂型和偏执型症状相关。研究了Sz先证者、注意力缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)先证者和社区对照(CC)先证者的一级亲属中APD的发生率。进一步分析在控制分裂型(SPD)和偏执型(PPD)人格障碍存在的情况下的发生率、相对组之间APD症状的差异,以及Sz患者亲属中的APD是否反映了另一种Sz谱系PD的“准发作”。对362名Sz先证者的一级亲属、201名ADHD先证者的亲属和245名CC先证者的亲属进行了访谈,以了解DSM-III-R轴I和轴II障碍的存在情况。综合家族史、访谈信息和病历确定诊断。与CC先证者相比,APD在Sz先证者的亲属中更频繁出现(p<0.001),在控制SPD和PPD时也是如此(p<0.005)。APD的两个症状是Sz先证者亲属最具特征性的:“回避社交或职业活动……”和“夸大潜在困难……”。65%被诊断为APD的Sz先证者亲属距离DSM-III-R对SPD或PPD的诊断标准差不止一项。这表明APD是一种独立的Sz谱系障碍,而不仅仅是SPD或PPD的亚临床形式。