Hagman Brett T, Clifford Patrick R, Noel Nora E, Davis Christine M, Cramond Alexander J
University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, School of Public Health, New Brunswick, New Jersey, United States.
Addict Behav. 2007 Oct;32(10):2317-23. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2007.01.023. Epub 2007 Jan 23.
Collateral informants have been routinely included in substance abuse treatment research to corroborate subject self-reported alcohol and other drug use. However, only a few studies to date have examined subject-collateral correspondence with respect to non-clinical populations (e.g., college students). The purpose of the present study was to examine the associations between college students self-reported substance use and corresponding collateral (i.e., friends') reports. A total of 100 subject-collateral pairs were recruited from psychology courses at a large public university located in the Southeastern, United States. Subjects and collaterals provided information specific to their own, as well as their friend's, recent (i.e., last 90-days) substance use. Study data yielded moderate to good, statistically significant, correlations between subject-friend pairs for each type of substance use. Discrepancy analyses revealed that the majority of subjects reported greater substance use relative to their collateral reports. This pattern of response (i.e., subject reporting greater use) is consistent with the extant literature. In addition, the friend's personal substance use appeared to influence his/her report of the subject's alcohol and other drug use. It appears that college student self-reports regarding alcohol and other drug use are reasonably accurate.
在药物滥用治疗研究中,通常会纳入旁证信息提供者,以证实受试者自我报告的酒精及其他药物使用情况。然而,迄今为止,仅有少数研究考察了非临床人群(如大学生)中受试者与旁证报告的一致性。本研究的目的是检验大学生自我报告的物质使用情况与相应旁证(即朋友)报告之间的关联。在美国东南部一所大型公立大学的心理学课程中,共招募了100对受试者-旁证组合。受试者和旁证提供了关于他们自己以及其朋友近期(即过去90天)物质使用情况的具体信息。研究数据显示,每种物质使用类型的受试者-朋友组合之间存在中度到良好的、具有统计学意义的相关性。差异分析表明,大多数受试者报告的物质使用量相对于其旁证报告更多。这种反应模式(即受试者报告使用量更多)与现有文献一致。此外,朋友自身的物质使用情况似乎会影响其对受试者酒精及其他药物使用情况的报告。大学生关于酒精及其他药物使用的自我报告似乎相当准确。