Maguire J, Ryan D
Department of Nursing and Health Science, Athlone Institute of Technology, Athlone, Co. Westmeath, Ireland.
J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs. 2007 Apr;14(2):120-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2850.2007.01051.x.
There is growing evidence that nurses in mental health services are likely to be victims of violence or aggression. One of the key difficulties in comparing international findings, however, has been that there has been an inadequate categorization of the types of incident to which staff are exposed. The current study aimed to identify the types of violent or aggressive incidents that staff in Irish Mental Health Services were exposed to within a 1-month long period. A cross-sectional study was undertaken with all nurses working in one of the Mental Health Services in Ireland, serving both an urban and rural population. Data were collected through a questionnaire (Scale of Aggressive and Violent Experiences) adapted from the Perceptions of Prevalence of Aggression Scale. The questionnaire was designed to collect data relating to both personal and professional demographics of the sample as well as experiences of aggressive or violent incidents respondents may have encountered in their work situation. There was a response rate of 31%. Data were analysed utilizing SPSS-11. Both descriptive and inferential analyses were undertaken. The relevant data were subjected to a series of one-way ANOVAS and chi-squared analysis. The findings suggest that nursing staff in this Mental Health Service experienced high levels of verbal aggression, with distinctions obvious between threatening and non-threatening aggression, suggesting discernment in terms of intentionality. Additionally, respondents encountered greater levels of covert or indirect violence or aggression than forms that were overtly directed towards staff. The implications are discussed in relation to both policy and practice.
越来越多的证据表明,心理健康服务领域的护士很可能成为暴力或攻击行为的受害者。然而,比较国际研究结果的一个关键困难在于,工作人员所遭遇的事件类型分类并不充分。当前的研究旨在确定爱尔兰心理健康服务机构的工作人员在为期1个月的时间内所遭遇的暴力或攻击事件的类型。对爱尔兰一家为城乡人口服务的心理健康服务机构中的所有护士进行了一项横断面研究。通过一份改编自《攻击行为发生率认知量表》的问卷(《攻击与暴力经历量表》)收集数据。该问卷旨在收集与样本的个人和职业人口统计学相关的数据,以及受访者在工作中可能遇到的攻击或暴力事件的经历。回复率为31%。利用SPSS - 11对数据进行分析。进行了描述性分析和推断性分析。相关数据进行了一系列单因素方差分析和卡方分析。研究结果表明,这家心理健康服务机构的护理人员经历了高水平的言语攻击,威胁性攻击和非威胁性攻击之间的区别明显,这表明在意图方面存在辨别力。此外,受访者遭遇的隐蔽或间接暴力或攻击比直接针对工作人员的形式更多。从政策和实践两方面对这些影响进行了讨论。