Pirotte Benoit, Acerbi Francesco, Lubansu Alphonse, Goldman Serge, Brotchi Jacques, Levivier Marc
Department of Neurosurgery, Hôpital Erasme, Université Libre de Bruxelles, 808 route de Lennik, 1070, Brussels, Belgium.
Childs Nerv Syst. 2007 Jul;23(7):739-51. doi: 10.1007/s00381-007-0307-8. Epub 2007 Mar 14.
The present article illustrates whether positron-emission tomography (PET) imaging may improve the surgical management of pediatric brain tumors (PBT) at different steps.
Among 400 consecutive PBT treated between 1995 and 2005 at Erasme Hospital, Brussels, Belgium, we have studied with (18) F-2-fluoro-2-deoxy-D-glucose (FDG)-PET and/or L-(methyl-(11)C)methionine (MET)-PET and integrated PET images in the diagnostic workup of 126 selected cases. The selection criteria were mainly based on the lesion appearance on magnetic resonance (MR) sequences. Cases were selected when MR imaging showed limitations for (1) assessing the evolving nature of an incidental lesion (n = 54), (2) selecting targets for contributive and accurate biopsy (n = 32), and (3) delineating tumor tissue for maximal resection (n = 40). Whenever needed, PET images were integrated in the planning of image-guided surgical procedures (frame-based stereotactic biopsies (SB), frameless navigation-based resections, or leksell gamma knife radiosurgery).
Like in adults, PET imaging really helped the surgical management of the 126 children explored, which represented about 30% of all PBT, especially when the newly diagnosed brain lesion was (1) an incidental finding so that the choice between surgery and conservative MR follow-up was debated, and (2) so infiltrative or ill-defined on MR that the choice between biopsy and resection was hardly discussed. Integrating PET into the diagnostic workup of these two selected groups helped to (1) take a more appropriate decision in incidental lesions by detecting tumor/evolving tissue; (2) better understand complex cases by differentiating indolent and active components of the lesion; (3) improve target selection and diagnostic yield of stereotactic biopsies in gliomas; (4) illustrate the intratumoral histological heterogeneity in gliomas; (5) provide additional prognostic information; (6) reduce the number of trajectories in biopsies performed in eloquent areas such as the brainstem or the pineal region; (7) better delineate ill-defined PBT infiltrative along functional cortex than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI); (8) increase significantly, compared to using MRI alone, the number of total tumor resection and the amount of tumor tissue removed in PBT for which a total resection is a key-factor of survival; (9) target the resection on more active areas; (10) improve detection of tumor residues in the operative cavity at the early postoperative stage; (11) facilitate the decision of early second-look surgery for optimizing the radical resection; (12) improve the accuracy of the radiosurgical dosimetry planning.
PET imaging may improve the surgical management of PBT at the diagnostic, surgical, and post-operative steps. Integration of PET in the clinical workup of PBT inaugurates a new approach in which functional data can influence the therapeutic decision process. Although metabolic information from PET are valid and relevant for the clinical purposes, further studies are needed to assess whether PET-guidance may decrease surgical morbidity and increase children survival.
本文阐述正电子发射断层扫描(PET)成像是否能在不同阶段改善小儿脑肿瘤(PBT)的手术治疗。
在1995年至2005年间于比利时布鲁塞尔伊拉斯谟医院接受治疗的400例连续PBT患儿中,我们对126例选定病例进行了(18)F - 2 - 氟 - 2 - 脱氧 - D - 葡萄糖(FDG) - PET和/或L - (甲基 - (11)C)蛋氨酸(MET) - PET检查,并在诊断检查中整合了PET图像。选择标准主要基于病变在磁共振(MR)序列上的表现。当MR成像在以下方面显示出局限性时选择病例:(1)评估偶然发现病变的演变性质(n = 54);(2)选择有助于进行准确活检的靶点(n = 32);(3)勾勒肿瘤组织以实现最大程度切除(n = 40)。必要时,PET图像被整合到图像引导手术程序(基于框架的立体定向活检(SB)、基于无框架导航的切除术或Leksell伽玛刀放射外科手术)的规划中。
与成人情况类似,PET成像确实有助于对所研究的126例儿童进行手术治疗,这些儿童约占所有PBT的30%,特别是当新诊断的脑病变为:(1)偶然发现,以至于在手术和保守MR随访之间的选择存在争议;(2)在MR上浸润性强或边界不清,以至于活检和切除之间的选择几乎无需讨论。将PET整合到这两个选定组的诊断检查中有助于:(1)通过检测肿瘤/演变组织,对偶然发现的病变做出更合适的决策;(2)通过区分病变的惰性和活跃成分,更好地理解复杂病例;(3)改善胶质瘤立体定向活检的靶点选择和诊断率;(4)阐明胶质瘤肿瘤内的组织学异质性;(5)提供额外的预后信息;(6)减少在脑干或松果体区等功能区进行活检时的穿刺路径数量;(7)比磁共振成像(MRI)更好地勾勒沿功能皮层浸润的边界不清的PBT;(8)与单独使用MRI相比,显著增加了PBT中全肿瘤切除的数量以及切除的肿瘤组织量,对于全切除是生存关键因素的PBT而言;(9)将切除目标定位于更活跃的区域;(10)提高术后早期手术腔隙内肿瘤残留的检测率;(11)便于决定早期二次手术以优化根治性切除;(12)提高放射外科剂量测定规划的准确性。
PET成像可在诊断、手术及术后阶段改善PBT的手术治疗。将PET整合到PBT的临床检查中开创了一种新方法,其中功能数据可影响治疗决策过程。尽管来自PET的代谢信息对临床目的有效且相关,但仍需进一步研究以评估PET引导是否可降低手术发病率并提高儿童生存率。