Röder Brigitte, Kusmierek Anna, Spence Charles, Schicke Tobias
Biological Psychology and Neuropsychology, University of Hamburg, Von-Melle-Park 11, D-20146 Hamburg, Germany.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2007 Mar 13;104(11):4753-8. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0607158104. Epub 2007 Mar 7.
Both animal and human studies suggest that action goals are defined in external coordinates regardless of their sensory modality. The present study used an auditory-manual task to test whether the default use of such an external reference frame is innately determined or instead acquired during development because of the increasing dominance of vision over manual control. In Experiment I, congenitally blind, late blind, and age-matched sighted adults had to press a left or right response key depending on the bandwidth of pink noise bursts presented from either the left or right loudspeaker. Although the spatial location of the sounds was entirely task-irrelevant, all groups responded more efficiently with uncrossed hands when the sound was presented from the same side as the responding hand ("Simon effect"). This effect reversed with crossed hands only in the congenitally blind: They responded faster with the hand that was located contralateral to the sound source. In Experiment II, the instruction to the participants was changed: They now had to respond with the hand located next to the sound source. In contrast to Experiment I ("Simon-task"), this task required an explicit matching of the sound's location with the position of the responding hand. In Experiment II, the congenitally blind participants showed a significantly larger crossing deficit than both the sighted and late blind adults. This pattern of results implies that developmental vision induces the default use of an external coordinate frame for multisensory action control; this facilitates not only visual but also auditory-manual control.
动物研究和人体研究均表明,行动目标是以外在坐标来定义的,而与其感官模态无关。本研究采用了一项听觉-手动任务,以测试这种外在参照系的默认使用是天生决定的,还是由于视觉在手动控制中日益占主导地位而在发育过程中习得的。在实验一中,先天失明、后天失明以及年龄匹配的视力正常的成年人需要根据从左侧或右侧扬声器发出的粉红噪声脉冲的带宽按下左侧或右侧的反应键。尽管声音的空间位置与任务完全无关,但当声音从与反应手同侧发出时,所有组使用未交叉的手反应更高效(“西蒙效应”)。这种效应只有在先天失明者中,当手交叉时才会反转:他们用与声源对侧的手反应更快。在实验二中,对参与者的指示发生了变化:他们现在必须用靠近声源的手做出反应。与实验一(“西蒙任务”)不同,这个任务需要将声音的位置与反应手的位置进行明确匹配。在实验二中,先天失明的参与者表现出比视力正常和后天失明的成年人更大的交叉缺陷。这种结果模式意味着,发育过程中的视觉诱导了用于多感官行动控制的外在坐标框架的默认使用;这不仅促进了视觉控制,也促进了听觉-手动控制。