Muñoz-Rivas Marina J, Graña Jose Luis, O'Leary K Daniel, González M Pilar
Department of Biological Psychology and Health Psychology, Psychology Faculty, Autonomous University of Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
J Adolesc Health. 2007 Apr;40(4):298-304. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2006.11.137. Epub 2007 Feb 20.
To assess the prevalence of verbally and physically aggressive behaviors in dating relationships in a sample of Spanish adolescents.
Cross-sectional self-report data were obtained with The Modified Conflict Tactics Scale (MCTS) from a representative sample of 2416 adolescents and young adults of both genders, between ages of 16 and 20 years.
The results showed that a significantly higher percentage of women engaged in verbal aggression (95.3% vs. 92.8%), whereas the males engaged in more severe physical aggression (4.6% vs. 2.0%) and produced worse consequences for their female partners' health (especially slight cuts/slight bruises, broken nose, black eye, broken bone and requiring medical treatment/hospitalization). Justification for aggression also revealed differential results. Whereas women said they attacked their partners while under the influence of emotional states of intense anger (22.4% vs. 13.9%), the males said they did so in response to aggression received (13.0% vs. 6.6%). The analysis of the group differences as a function of age showed that verbal aggression was very high and was not different across the age groups. In contrast, physical aggression decreased significantly across the age groups, but health consequences became more severe with age (e.g., broken nose, black eye, broken bone, went from 1% at 16 years to 4.5% at 20 years of age).
These differential tendencies of aggression typology for men and women help clinicians to develop preventive interventions for every age, with the aim of diminishing their continuity in future relationships.
评估西班牙青少年约会关系中言语和身体攻击行为的发生率。
采用修订后的冲突策略量表(MCTS),对2416名年龄在16至20岁之间的男女青少年和青年进行代表性抽样,获取横断面自我报告数据。
结果显示,女性实施言语攻击的比例显著更高(95.3%对92.8%),而男性实施更严重身体攻击的比例更高(4.6%对2.0%),且对其女性伴侣的健康造成更严重后果(尤其是轻微割伤/轻微擦伤、鼻梁骨折、黑眼圈、骨折以及需要就医/住院)。攻击行为的理由也显示出差异。女性表示她们在极度愤怒的情绪状态下攻击伴侣(22.4%对13.9%),而男性表示他们是对所遭受的攻击做出回应(13.0%对6.6%)。对年龄组差异的分析表明,言语攻击非常普遍,且各年龄组之间没有差异。相比之下,身体攻击在各年龄组中显著减少,但健康后果随年龄增长而变得更严重(例如,鼻梁骨折、黑眼圈、骨折,从16岁时的1%上升到20岁时的4.5%)。
男女攻击类型的这些差异趋势有助于临床医生为每个年龄段制定预防干预措施,以减少其在未来关系中的持续性。