Nguyen Tung T, Gildengorin Ginny, Truong Amy, McPhee Stephen J
Suc Khoe La Vang! (Health is Gold!), Vietnamese Community Health Promotion Project, Division of General Internal Medicine, Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA 94143-0320, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2007 Apr;22(4):523-6. doi: 10.1007/s11606-007-0128-1.
Little is known about physicians' screening patterns for liver cancer despite its rising incidence.
Describe physician factors associated with liver cancer screening.
Mailed survey.
Physicians practicing in family practice, internal medicine, gastroenterology, or nephrology in 3 northern California counties in 2004.
Sociodemographic and practice measures, liver cancer knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported screening behaviors.
The response rate was 61.8% (N = 459). Gastroenterologists (100%) were more likely than Internists (88.4%), family practitioners (84.2%), or nephrologists (75.0%) to screen for liver cancer in high-risk patients (p = 0.016). In multivariate analysis, screeners were more likely than nonscreeners to think that screening for liver cancer reduced mortality (odds ratio [OR] 1.60, CI 1.09-2.34) and that not screening was a malpractice risk (OR 1.88, CI 1.29-2.75). Screeners were more likely than nonscreeners to order any screening test if it was a quality of care measure (OR 4.39, CI 1.79-10.81).
Despite debate about screening efficacy, many physicians screen for liver cancer. Their screening behavior is influenced by malpractice and quality control concerns. More research is needed to develop better screening tests for liver cancer, to evaluate their effectiveness, and to understand how physicians behave when there is insufficient evidence.
尽管肝癌发病率不断上升,但对于医生的肝癌筛查模式却知之甚少。
描述与肝癌筛查相关的医生因素。
邮寄调查问卷。
2004年在加利福尼亚州北部3个县从事家庭医学、内科、胃肠病学或肾脏病学工作的医生。
社会人口统计学和执业情况指标、肝癌知识、态度以及自我报告的筛查行为。
回复率为61.8%(N = 459)。胃肠病科医生(100%)在高危患者中进行肝癌筛查的可能性高于内科医生(88.4%)、家庭医生(84.2%)或肾病科医生(75.0%)(p = 0.016)。在多变量分析中,与不进行筛查的医生相比,进行筛查的医生更有可能认为肝癌筛查可降低死亡率(优势比[OR] 1.60,CI 1.09 - 2.34),且不进行筛查存在医疗过失风险(OR 1.88,CI 1.29 - 2.75)。如果将某项筛查视为医疗质量指标,那么与不进行筛查的医生相比,进行筛查的医生更有可能开具任何筛查检查单(OR 4.39,CI 1.79 - 10.81)。
尽管对于筛查效果存在争议,但许多医生仍进行肝癌筛查。他们的筛查行为受到医疗过失和质量控制问题的影响。需要开展更多研究来开发更好的肝癌筛查检查,评估其有效性,并了解在证据不足时医生的行为表现。