Bunton Bryan, O'shaughnessy Patrick, Fitzsimmons Sean, Gering John, Hoff Stephen, Lyngbye Merete, Thorne Peter S, Wasson Jeffrey, Werner Mark
Iowa Department of Natural Resources, Des Moines, Iowa, USA.
Environ Health Perspect. 2007 Feb;115(2):303-7. doi: 10.1289/ehp.8838. Epub 2006 Nov 14.
Accurate monitors are required to determine ambient concentration levels of contaminants emanating from concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs), and accurate models are required to indicate the spatial variability of concentrations over regions affected by CAFOs. A thorough understanding of the spatial and temporal variability of concentration levels could then be associated with locations of healthy individuals or subjects with respiratory ailments to statistically link the presence of CAFOs to the prevalence of ill health effects in local populations. This workgroup report, which was part of the Conference on Environmental Health Impacts of Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations: Anticipating Hazards-Searching for Solutions, describes instrumentation currently available for assessing contaminant concentration levels in the vicinity of CAFOs and reviews plume dispersion models that may be used to estimate concentration levels spatially. Recommendations for further research with respect to ambient air monitoring include accurately determining long-term average concentrations for a region under the influence of CAFO emissions using a combination of instruments based on accuracy, cost, and sampling duration. In addition, development of instruments capable of accurately quantifying adsorbed gases and volatile organic compounds is needed. Further research with respect to plume dispersion models includes identifying and validating the most applicable model for use in predicting downwind concentrations from CAFOs. Additional data are needed to obtain reliable emission rates from CAFOs.
需要精确的监测器来测定集中式动物饲养场(CAFOs)排放的污染物的环境浓度水平,还需要精确的模型来指示受CAFOs影响区域内浓度的空间变异性。然后,对浓度水平的时空变异性的透彻理解可以与健康个体或患有呼吸系统疾病的受试者的位置相关联,以便从统计学上把CAFOs的存在与当地人群中健康不良影响的患病率联系起来。这份工作组报告是“集中式动物饲养场的环境健康影响会议:预测危害——寻找解决方案”的一部分,描述了目前可用于评估CAFOs附近污染物浓度水平的仪器,并回顾了可用于在空间上估计浓度水平的烟羽扩散模型。关于环境空气监测的进一步研究建议包括,基于准确性、成本和采样持续时间,结合使用多种仪器准确测定受CAFOs排放影响区域的长期平均浓度。此外,还需要开发能够准确量化吸附气体和挥发性有机化合物的仪器。关于烟羽扩散模型的进一步研究包括识别和验证最适用于预测CAFOs下风向浓度的模型。需要更多数据来获得CAFOs可靠的排放率。