Kianmanesh Reza, Scaringi Stefano, Sabate Jean-Marc, Castel Benjamin, Pons-Kerjean Nathalie, Coffin Benoit, Hay Jean-Marie, Flamant Yves, Msika Simon
Department of Surgery, Louis-Mourier University Hospital, Assistance Publique des Hôpitaux de Paris, Paris-VII University (GHU Nord), Colombes, France.
Ann Surg. 2007 Apr;245(4):597-603. doi: 10.1097/01.sla.0000255561.87771.11.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the results of an aggressive strategy in patients presenting peritoneal carcinomatosis (PC) from colorectal cancer with or without liver metastases (LMs) treated with cytoreductive surgery (CS) and hyperthermic intraperitoneal chemotherapy (HIPEC).
The population included 43 patients who had 54 CS+HIPEC for colorectal PC from 1996 to 2006. Sixteen patients (37%) presented LMs. Eleven patients (25%) presented occlusion at the time of PC diagnosis. Ascites was present in 12 patients (28%). Seventy-seven percent of the patients were Gilly 3 (diffuse nodules, 5-20 mm) and Gilly 4 (diffuse nodules>20 mm). The main endpoints were morbidity, mortality, completeness of cancer resection (CCR), and actuarial survival rates.
The CS was considered as CCR-0 (no residual nodules) or CCR-1 (residual nodules <5 mm) in 30 patients (70%). Iterative procedures were performed in 26% of patients. Three patients had prior to CS + HIPEC, 10 had concomitant minor liver resection, and 3 had differed liver resections (2 right hepatectomies) 2 months after CS + HIPEC. The mortality rate was 2.3% (1 patient). Seventeen patients (39%) presented one or multiple complications (per procedure morbidity = 31%). Complications included deep abscess (n = 6), wound infection (n = 5), pleural effusion (n = 5), digestive fistula (n = 4), delayed gastric emptying syndrome (n = 4), and renal failure (n = 3). Two patients (3.6%) were reoperated. The median survival was 38.4 months (CI, 32.8-43.9). Actuarial 2- and 4-year survival rates were 72% and 44%, respectively. The survival rates were not significantly different between patients who had CS + HIPEC for PC alone (including the primary resection) versus those who had associated LMs resection (median survival, 35.3 versus 36.0 months, P = 0.73).
Iterative CS + HIPEC is an effective treatment in PC from colorectal cancer. The presence of resectable LMs associated with PC does not contraindicate the prospect of an oncologic treatment in these patients.
本研究旨在评估积极治疗策略对患有或不伴有肝转移(LM)的结直肠癌腹膜癌(PC)患者进行细胞减灭术(CS)和腹腔热灌注化疗(HIPEC)后的治疗效果。
研究人群包括1996年至2006年间接受54次CS+HIPEC治疗结直肠癌PC的43例患者。16例患者(37%)存在肝转移。11例患者(25%)在PC诊断时出现肠梗阻。12例患者(28%)有腹水。77%的患者为Gilly 3期(弥漫性结节,5 - 20毫米)和Gilly 4期(弥漫性结节>20毫米)。主要终点指标为发病率、死亡率、癌症切除完整性(CCR)和精算生存率。
30例患者(70%)的CS被视为CCR - 0(无残留结节)或CCR - 1(残留结节<5毫米)。26%的患者进行了重复手术。3例患者在CS + HIPEC之前进行过手术,10例患者同时进行了小范围肝切除,3例患者在CS + HIPEC后2个月进行了延期肝切除(2例右半肝切除术)。死亡率为2.3%(1例患者)。17例患者(39%)出现一种或多种并发症(每次手术发病率 = 31%)。并发症包括深部脓肿(n = 6)、伤口感染(n = 5)、胸腔积液(n = 5)、消化瘘(n = 4)、胃排空延迟综合征(n = 4)和肾衰竭(n = 3)。2例患者(3.6%)接受了再次手术。中位生存期为38.4个月(CI,32.8 - 43.9)。精算2年和4年生存率分别为72%和44%。仅接受PC的CS + HIPEC治疗(包括原发灶切除)的患者与接受联合肝转移灶切除的患者生存率无显著差异(中位生存期,35.3个月对36.0个月,P = 0.73)。
重复CS + HIPEC是治疗结直肠癌PC的有效方法。与PC相关的可切除肝转移的存在并不排除这些患者接受肿瘤治疗的可能性。