Thorlakson B, Martin W, Peters D
Can Vet J. 1990 Aug;31(8):573-9.
A double blind, random, controlled field trial was conducted to ascertain the efficacy of a Pasteurella haemolytica bacterial extract (Presponse, Langford Inc., Guelph, Ontario) in the prevention of bovine respiratory disease and/or its effects. Calves from 13 ranches (n = 1140 calves) were assigned to one of four groups, namely: vaccinated at the ranch three weeks prior to shipping to the feedlot; vaccinated only on arrival at the feedlot; vaccinated at both locations; or not vaccinated at either location. Four replicates of auction calves (n = 731) were also assigned to either receive or not receive the vaccine on arrival at the feedlot.The vaccine did not effect a change in morbidity rates or weight gain. Total mortality rates were increased significantly, and mortality rates from respiratory disease tended to be increased in ranch calves that were vaccinated with Presponse at the ranch. In auction calves, the relapse rates were significantly lower in vaccinated calves. There was a tendency towards a reduction of respiratory disease-related mortality, however there appeared to be no sparing against death from fibrinous pneumonia in auction calves.
进行了一项双盲、随机、对照现场试验,以确定溶血巴斯德氏菌细菌提取物(Presponse,兰福德公司,安大略省圭尔夫)在预防牛呼吸道疾病和/或其影响方面的功效。来自13个牧场的犊牛(n = 1140头犊牛)被分为四组之一,即:在运往饲养场前三周在牧场接种疫苗;仅在到达饲养场时接种疫苗;在两个地点都接种疫苗;或在任何一个地点都不接种疫苗。还将四批拍卖犊牛(n = 731)分配为在到达饲养场时接受或不接受疫苗。该疫苗对发病率或体重增加没有影响。总死亡率显著增加,在牧场接种Presponse疫苗的牧场犊牛中,呼吸道疾病死亡率有增加的趋势。在拍卖犊牛中,接种疫苗的犊牛复发率显著较低。有降低呼吸道疾病相关死亡率的趋势,然而在拍卖犊牛中,似乎无法避免死于纤维素性肺炎。