Leighton S E, Robson A K, Freeland A P
Department of Otolaryngology, Radcliffe Infirmary, Oxford, UK.
Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci. 1991 Oct;16(5):488-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2273.1991.tb01046.x.
The number of stapedectomies performed annually has declined since 1963. Also, surgery has become available at an increasing number of centres, resulting in a further fall in the number of such operations performed in teaching hospitals. Several studies have suggested benefit might be gained, both by patients and by otology as a speciality, from limiting training to post-graduates who show an aptitude for otology, and concentrating surgery in a small number of specialized centres. We report a series of 179 patients who had stapedectomy performed for otosclerosis in a teaching hospital. We have retrospectively compared the audiological outcome and complication rates for consultants and surgical trainees. For the two groups, there is no significant difference in postoperative hearing levels and complication rates are similar. Our success rate is comparable to other major series. We conclude that stapedectomy is a safe procedure to teach adequately experienced and supervised trainees.
自1963年以来,每年进行的镫骨切除术数量有所下降。此外,越来越多的中心可以开展该手术,这导致教学医院此类手术的数量进一步减少。多项研究表明,将培训限制在表现出耳科学资质的研究生,并将手术集中在少数专业中心,患者和耳科学专业都可能从中受益。我们报告了在一家教学医院为耳硬化症进行镫骨切除术的179例患者。我们回顾性比较了顾问医生和外科实习生的听力结果和并发症发生率。两组术后听力水平无显著差异,并发症发生率相似。我们的成功率与其他主要系列相当。我们得出结论,镫骨切除术对于经验丰富且有监督的实习生来说是一种安全的手术教学方法。