Melville Katherine M, Casey Leanne M, Kavanagh David J
School of Psychology, Mt Gravatt Campus, Griffith University, Brisbane, Queensland, 4111, Australia.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2007 Dec;27(8):944-58. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2007.02.004. Epub 2007 Mar 2.
Premature dropout from treatments for pathological gambling is potentially of significant importance, if it occurs before substantial progress has been made in addressing the problem. A systematic review of current research on dropout from psychological treatments for pathological gambling identified 12 studies from five countries. Dropout ranged from 14% to 50%, with a median of dropout 26%. Overall, 31% of the participants dropped out of treatment. Few studies distinguish between dropouts at different stages of participation. The evidence on specific variables that predict dropout is limited or inconsistent, and is characterised by a lack of a coherent, gambling-specific model and by methodological problems. Two studies that attempted to apply motivational and compliance-enhancing techniques were found. Both showed promising effects on reduction of dropout and improvement of short-term impact of treatment, but inconsistent results on longer-term outcomes were obtained. The review highlighted a need for more rigorous investigation of the extent of dropout and of variables associated with dropout from pathological gambling treatment programs. Further research on interventions to enhance retention and reduce dropout from psychological treatment is also required.
如果在解决病理性赌博问题取得实质性进展之前就出现过早退出治疗的情况,这可能具有重大意义。一项对当前关于病理性赌博心理治疗退出情况的研究的系统评价,从五个国家中识别出了12项研究。退出率在14%至50%之间,退出率中位数为26%。总体而言,31%的参与者退出了治疗。很少有研究区分不同参与阶段的退出情况。关于预测退出的特定变量的证据有限或不一致,其特点是缺乏一个连贯的、针对赌博的模型以及存在方法学问题。发现了两项试图应用动机和依从性增强技术的研究。两者都显示出在减少退出和改善治疗短期效果方面有令人鼓舞的效果,但在长期结果上获得的结果不一致。该评价强调需要对病理性赌博治疗项目的退出程度以及与退出相关的变量进行更严格的调查。还需要进一步研究提高心理治疗留存率和减少退出的干预措施。