Ocak Sabahattin, Cetin Meryem, Hakverdi Sibel, Dolapcioglu Kenan, Gungoren Arif, Hakverdi Ali U
Department of Infectious Disease and Clinical Microbiology, Faculty of Medicine, Mustafa Kemal University, Antakya, Turkey.
Saudi Med J. 2007 May;28(5):727-31.
To investigate the microbial and cytopathological changes and genital symptoms in oral contraceptive pill (OCP) and intrauterine contraceptive device (IUCD) users.
Included in the study were 34 women using OCP and 34 women using IUCD for 24 to 36 months period and 34 women as control group. We conducted the study between March to September 2005 in Antakya Maternity Hospital, Turkey. Vaginal discharge was subjected to wet mount examination, gram staining, and culture. Cervical smears were examined and reported using the Bethesda system as reference.
In the IUCD group, women with intermediate score was 20.6%, while those with bacterial vaginosis was 11.7%. In the OCP group however, women with intermediate score was 8.8%, while those with bacterial vaginosis was 5.9%. Compared to the control group, these rates were 2.9% for those with intermediate score and 2.9% for those with bacterial vaginosis. Escherichia coli vaginal colonization increased by 5-fold in the IUCD users (p<0.05). Cervical erosion was found in 14.7% of the women using IUCD as compared to the other groups (p<0.05). Actinomyces like organisms was detected in 11.7% of the IUCD users (p<0.05).
The use of IUCD clearly alter the normal vaginal flora, although OCP appears to have minimal effects on the vaginal microbial flora. The data support the hypothesis that IUCD might change cervico vaginal environment, and suggests that women with IUCD may be at a higher risk for vulvovaginal infection.
调查口服避孕药(OCP)和宫内节育器(IUCD)使用者的微生物和细胞病理学变化以及生殖系统症状。
研究纳入了34名使用OCP 24至36个月的女性、34名使用IUCD 24至36个月的女性以及34名作为对照组的女性。研究于2005年3月至9月在土耳其安塔基亚妇产医院进行。对阴道分泌物进行湿片检查、革兰氏染色和培养。宫颈涂片采用贝塞斯达系统作为参考进行检查和报告。
在IUCD组中,中度评分的女性占20.6%,细菌性阴道病患者占11.7%。然而,在OCP组中,中度评分的女性占8.8%,细菌性阴道病患者占5.9%。与对照组相比,中度评分者的比例为2.9%,细菌性阴道病患者的比例为2.9%。IUCD使用者中大肠杆菌阴道定植增加了5倍(p<0.05)。与其他组相比,使用IUCD的女性中有14.7%发现宫颈糜烂(p<0.05)。在11.7%的IUCD使用者中检测到放线菌样微生物(p<0.05)。
IUCD的使用明显改变了正常阴道菌群,尽管OCP对阴道微生物菌群的影响似乎最小。这些数据支持IUCD可能改变宫颈阴道环境的假说,并表明使用IUCD的女性可能患外阴阴道感染的风险更高。