Ashley William W, Baty Jack D, Hollander Trisha, Noetzel Michael J, Park Tae Sung
Departments of Neurosurgery, St. Louis Children's Hospital, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri 63110-1077, USA.
J Neurosurg. 2007 Apr;106(4 Suppl):276-81. doi: 10.3171/ped.2007.106.4.276.
Due to the complex and variable nature of brachial plexus injury, outcome analysis can be cumbersome and imprecise. Many scales have been devised, but no single scale is used uniformly. Moreover, despite several studies in which the authors have reported brachial plexus surgical data, no highly predictive clinical model has been defined.
In this study the authors performed a retrospective analysis of 114 consecutive brachial plexus surgeries performed by the senior author during the past 14 years at St. Louis Children's Hospital. Of these, 63 are included in this study. The authors defined the motor score composite (MSC) and used this novel metric to perform a detailed analysis of their surgical outcomes. The mean MSC was 0.50 preoperatively, 0.71 at 1 year postoperatively, and 0.80 at 2 years postoperatively. By 2 years postoperatively, 89% of the patients attained a good or excellent recovery. Age at surgery, time to visit, location, and severity were predictive of outcome. Using MSC data, the authors developed a prognostic model that enabled the prediction (with 88% accuracy) of surgical outcomes using preoperative variables.
The MSC is an efficient metric for the reporting of data regarding outcomes of brachial plexus injury. It provides information about extent and severity of injury in a single proportion and facilitates complex data analysis. The authors used the MSC model to accurately predict surgical outcome. This metric could have wide applicability for the prediction of postoperative recovery to improve both surgical decision making and family counseling.
由于臂丛神经损伤的性质复杂且多变,结果分析可能既繁琐又不精确。已经设计了许多评分系统,但没有一个评分系统被统一使用。此外,尽管有几项研究报告了臂丛神经手术数据,但尚未定义出具有高度预测性的临床模型。
在本研究中,作者对资深作者在过去14年于圣路易斯儿童医院连续进行的114例臂丛神经手术进行了回顾性分析。其中,63例纳入本研究。作者定义了运动评分综合指标(MSC),并使用这一新指标对手术结果进行了详细分析。术前平均MSC为0.50,术后1年为0.71,术后2年为0.80。术后2年时,89%的患者恢复良好或极佳。手术时年龄、就诊时间、损伤部位和严重程度可预测结果。利用MSC数据,作者开发了一种预后模型,该模型能够使用术前变量预测手术结果(准确率达88%)。
MSC是报告臂丛神经损伤结果数据的有效指标。它以单一比例提供有关损伤范围和严重程度的信息,并便于进行复杂的数据分析。作者使用MSC模型准确预测了手术结果。该指标在预测术后恢复方面可能具有广泛的适用性,有助于改善手术决策和为家属提供咨询。