Fahmida Umi, Rumawas Johanna S P, Utomo Budi, Patmonodewo Soemiarti, Schultink Werner
SEAMEO-TROPMED, RCCN, University of Indonesia, Salemba Raya 6, Jakarta-10430.
Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2007;16(2):301-9.
Zinc supplementation has been shown to benefit linear growth. However the effect may depend on whether zinc is the most limiting nutrient. This study aims to investigate the effect of supplementation with zinc-given alone or with iron and vitamin-A in improving infantsf micronutrient status and linear growth. The study was a double-blind-community-intervention study involving 800 infants aged 3-6 months in rural East Lombok, West Nusa Tenggara. Syrup consisting of zinc-alone, Zn (10 mg/d), zinc+iron, Zn+Fe (10 mg/d of each), zinc+iron+vitamin-A, Zn+Fe+vit.A (10 mg/d of each zinc and iron plus 1,000 IU vitamin-A), or placebo were given daily for six months. Outcomes measured were length, weight, and micronutrient status (haemoglobin, se-rum zinc, ferritin and retinol). Zn+Fe and Zn+Fe+vit.A supplementations benefit zinc and iron status of the sub-jects, while Zn-alone supplementation disadvantaged haemoglobin and iron status. The highest increment in vi-tamin A and haemoglobin status was shown in Zn+Fe+vit.A group. An effect on linear growth was observed among initially-stunted subjects in Zn+Fe and Zn+Fe+vit.A groups who grew 1.1-1.5 cm longer than placebo. On the other hand, in the Zn-alone group, mean height-for-age Z-score decreased to a greater extent than placebo. The between-group difference in HAZ among initially-stunted subjects was significant after four months sup-plementation. While the difference was not significant in follow-up after 6 months, the pattern remained the same where means height-for-age Z-score in Zn+Fe+vit.A and Zn+Fe groups were higher than placebo and Zn-alone groups. Given the low haemoglobin/iron status of the subjects, zinc supplementation would have positive effect on growth if the low haemoglobin/iron status is also addressed and corrected.
锌补充剂已被证明有利于线性生长。然而,其效果可能取决于锌是否是最具限制性的营养素。本研究旨在调查单独补充锌或与铁和维生素A一起补充对改善婴儿微量营养素状况和线性生长的影响。该研究是一项双盲社区干预研究,涉及西努沙登加拉省东龙目岛农村地区的800名3至6个月大的婴儿。单独含锌(10毫克/天)、锌+铁(各10毫克/天)、锌+铁+维生素A(锌和铁各10毫克/天加1000国际单位维生素A)或安慰剂的糖浆每天服用六个月。测量的结果包括身长、体重和微量营养素状况(血红蛋白、血清锌、铁蛋白和视黄醇)。锌+铁和锌+铁+维生素A补充剂有益于受试者的锌和铁状况,而单独补充锌则不利于血红蛋白和铁状况。锌+铁+维生素A组的维生素A和血红蛋白状况增幅最大。在锌+铁和锌+铁+维生素A组中,最初发育迟缓的受试者的线性生长有改善,比安慰剂组多生长1.1至1.5厘米。另一方面,在单独补充锌的组中,年龄别身高Z评分的下降幅度比安慰剂组更大。在最初发育迟缓的受试者中,补充四个月后组间身高别年龄Z评分差异显著。虽然六个月随访时差异不显著,但模式保持不变,锌+铁+维生素A组和锌+铁组的年龄别身高Z评分均值高于安慰剂组和单独补充锌的组。鉴于受试者血红蛋白/铁水平较低,如果低血红蛋白/铁状况也得到解决和纠正,锌补充剂对生长将有积极影响。