Zimmermann Christa, Del Piccolo Lidia, Finset Arnstein
Department of Medicine and Public Health, Section of Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology, University of Verona, Verona, Italy.
Psychol Bull. 2007 May;133(3):438-63. doi: 10.1037/0033-2909.133.3.438.
The aim of the current article is to review the peer-reviewed research literature on cues and concerns published between 1975 and 2006. To be included, articles had to report observational studies based on patient-physician consultations and report findings on patient expressions of cues and/or concerns. Quantitative and qualitative studies from different medical settings were considered. Fifty-eight original articles based on the analysis of audio- or videotaped medical consultations were tracked down. Definition of cues and concerns and methodological approaches differed widely. Physicians missed most cues and concerns and adopted behaviors that discouraged disclosure. Communication training improved the detection of cues and concerns. Future research progress would require different methodological approaches more appropriate for studying verbal interactions and the complexity of the various levels that influence interactions.
本文的目的是回顾1975年至2006年间发表的关于线索和担忧的同行评审研究文献。要纳入的文章必须报告基于医患咨询的观察性研究,并报告患者线索和/或担忧表达的研究结果。考虑了来自不同医疗环境的定量和定性研究。通过对音频或视频医疗咨询的分析,找到了58篇原创文章。线索和担忧的定义以及方法学方法差异很大。医生大多错过了线索和担忧,并采取了阻碍信息披露的行为。沟通培训提高了对线索和担忧的察觉。未来的研究进展将需要更适合研究言语互动以及影响互动的各个层面复杂性的不同方法学方法。