Sham C O, Cheng Y W, Ho K W, Lai P H, Lo L W, Wan H L, Wong C Y, Yeung Y N, Yuen S H, Wong A Y
University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
J Med Ethics. 2007 May;33(5):261-5. doi: 10.1136/jme.2005.014423.
To study the attitudes of both medical and non-medical students towards the do-not-resuscitate (DNR) decision in a university in Hong Kong, and the factors affecting their attitudes.
A questionnaire-based survey conducted in the campus of a university in Hong Kong. Preferences and priorities of participants on cardiopulmonary resuscitation in various situations and case scenarios, experience of death and dying, prior knowledge of DNR and basic demographic data were evaluated.
A total of 766 students participated in the study. There were statistically significant differences in their DNR decisions in various situations between medical and non-medical students, clinical and preclinical students, and between students who had previously experienced death and dying and those who had not. A prior knowledge of DNR significantly affected DNR decision, although 66.4% of non-medical students and 18.7% of medical students had never heard of DNR. 74% of participants from both medical and non-medical fields considered the patient's own wish as the most important factor that the healthcare team should consider when making DNR decisions. Family wishes might not be decisive on the choice of DNR.
Students in medical and non-medical fields held different views on DNR. A majority of participants considered the patient's own wish as most important in DNR decisions. Family wishes were considered less important than the patient's own wishes.
研究香港一所大学医学和非医学专业学生对不进行心肺复苏(DNR)决定的态度,以及影响他们态度的因素。
在香港一所大学的校园内进行基于问卷的调查。评估了参与者在各种情况和案例场景下对心肺复苏的偏好和优先级、死亡和濒死经历、DNR的先验知识以及基本人口统计学数据。
共有766名学生参与了该研究。医学和非医学专业学生、临床和临床前学生之间,以及之前有过死亡和濒死经历的学生与没有此类经历的学生之间,在各种情况下的DNR决定存在统计学上的显著差异。DNR的先验知识显著影响DNR决定,尽管66.4%的非医学专业学生和18.7%的医学专业学生从未听说过DNR。医学和非医学领域的74%的参与者认为患者自身的意愿是医疗团队在做出DNR决定时应考虑的最重要因素。家庭意愿在DNR选择上可能不是决定性的。
医学和非医学领域的学生对DNR持有不同观点。大多数参与者认为患者自身的意愿在DNR决定中最为重要。家庭意愿被认为不如患者自身意愿重要。