Maffiuletti Nicola A, Jubeau Marc, Munzinger Urs, Bizzini Mario, Agosti Fiorenza, De Col Alessandra, Lafortuna Claudio L, Sartorio Alessandro
Neuromuscular Research Laboratory, Schulthess Klinik, Lengghalde 2, 8008, Zurich, Switzerland.
Eur J Appl Physiol. 2007 Sep;101(1):51-9. doi: 10.1007/s00421-007-0471-2. Epub 2007 May 3.
The present study aimed to compare quadriceps femoris muscle strength and fatigue between obese (grade II and III) and nonobese adults. Ten obese (mean age: 25 years; mean BMI: 41 kg/m(2)) and ten lean (mean age: 27 years; mean BMI: 23 kg/m(2)) men were tested. Quadriceps muscle fatigue was quantified as the (percent) torque loss during a voluntary isokinetic (50 maximal contractions at 180 degrees /s) and an electrostimulated (40 Hz) isometric protocol (5 min, 10% of the maximal torque). Maximal voluntary isometric and isokinetic torque and power were also measured. Voluntary torque loss was significantly higher (P < 0.05) in obese (-63.5%) than in lean subjects (-50.6%). Stimulated torque decreased significantly (P < 0.05) but equally in the two subject groups. Obese subjects displayed higher absolute (+20%; P < 0.01) but lower relative (i.e., normalized to body mass) (-32%; P < 0.001) muscle torque and power than their lean counterparts. Obese individuals demonstrated lower fatigue resistance during voluntary but not during stimulated knee extensions compared to their nonobese counterparts. Peripheral mechanisms of muscle fatigue -- at least those associated to the present stimulated test -- were not influenced by obesity. The observed quadriceps muscle function impairments (voluntary fatigue and relative strength) probably contribute to the reduced functional capacity of obese subjects during daily living activities.
本研究旨在比较肥胖(II级和III级)和非肥胖成年人的股四头肌力量与疲劳程度。对10名肥胖男性(平均年龄:25岁;平均体重指数:41kg/m²)和10名瘦男性(平均年龄:27岁;平均体重指数:23kg/m²)进行了测试。股四头肌疲劳程度通过在自愿等速运动(180度/秒下进行50次最大收缩)和电刺激(40Hz)等长运动方案(5分钟,最大扭矩的10%)期间的(百分比)扭矩损失来量化。还测量了最大自愿等长和等速扭矩及功率。肥胖者的自愿扭矩损失(-63.5%)显著高于瘦受试者(-50.6%)(P<0.05)。刺激扭矩在两组受试者中均显著下降(P<0.05),但下降程度相同。肥胖受试者的绝对肌肉扭矩和功率更高(+20%;P<0.01),但相对(即相对于体重归一化)更低(-32%;P<0.001)。与非肥胖者相比,肥胖个体在自愿进行膝关节伸展时表现出较低的抗疲劳能力,但在电刺激时则不然。肌肉疲劳的外周机制——至少是与当前刺激测试相关的那些机制——不受肥胖的影响。观察到的股四头肌功能损害(自愿性疲劳和相对力量)可能导致肥胖受试者在日常生活活动中的功能能力下降。