Emond Alice, Ormel Johan, Veenstra René, Oldehinkel Albertine J
Department of Psychiatry and Graduate School of Behavioral and Cognitive Neurosciences, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, PO Box 30001, Groningen 9700 RB, The Netherlands.
Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2007 Oct;38(3):221-36. doi: 10.1007/s10578-007-0058-5. Epub 2007 May 3.
This article describes preschool social understanding and difficult behaviors (hot temper, disobedience, bossiness and bullying) as predictors of oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and aggressive conduct disorder (ACD) in a Dutch population sample of (pre)adolescents (N = 1943), measured at age 10-12 and at age 13-15. ODD and ACD were assessed by the Child Behavior Checklist and the Youth Self-Report, preschool behavior was evaluated by the parental questionnaire [Symbol: see text]How was your child as a preschooler? (age 4-5)'. Adjusted for each other, all difficult preschool behaviors except bullying were associated with adolescent ODD, while only bullying significantly predicted adolescent ACD. Furthermore, the results suggest a qualitative difference between ODD and ACD in terms of the social component of the disorders: poor preschool social understanding was associated with the development of ACD but not of ODD; and poor social understanding interacted with difficult preschool behaviors to predict later ACD but not ODD. The associations did not differ between boys and girls, and were roughly similar for preadolescent (age 10-12) and early adolescent (age 13-15) outcomes. The finding that poor social understanding was implicated in the development of ACD but not in the development of ODD may help to demarcate the individuality of each disorder and offer leads for (differential) treatment strategies.
本文描述了学前儿童的社会理解能力和困难行为(脾气暴躁、不听话、专横和欺负行为),这些被视为荷兰(学前)青少年群体样本(N = 1943)中对立违抗障碍(ODD)和攻击性行为障碍(ACD)的预测因素,该样本在10至12岁以及13至15岁时进行了测量。ODD和ACD通过儿童行为量表和青少年自我报告进行评估,学前行为通过家长问卷“您的孩子在学龄前(4至5岁)时是什么样的?”进行评估。相互调整后,除欺负行为外,所有学前困难行为均与青少年ODD相关,而只有欺负行为能显著预测青少年ACD。此外,结果表明,ODD和ACD在障碍的社会成分方面存在质的差异:学前社会理解能力差与ACD的发展相关,但与ODD无关;社会理解能力差与学前困难行为相互作用,可预测后期的ACD,但不能预测ODD。男孩和女孩之间的关联没有差异,对于青春期前(10至12岁)和青春期早期(13至15岁)的结果大致相似。社会理解能力差与ACD的发展有关但与ODD的发展无关这一发现,可能有助于区分每种障碍的个体特征,并为(差异)治疗策略提供线索。