Hoskins Sally G, Stevens Leslie M, Nehm Ross H
Biology Department and The Graduate Center, The City College of the City University of New York, New York, New York 10031, USA.
Genetics. 2007 Jul;176(3):1381-9. doi: 10.1534/genetics.107.071183. Epub 2007 May 4.
CREATE (consider, read, elucidate hypotheses, analyze and interpret the data, and think of the next experiment) is a new method for teaching science and the nature of science through primary literature. CREATE uses a unique combination of novel pedagogical tools to guide undergraduates through analysis of journal articles, highlighting the evolution of scientific ideas by focusing on a module of four articles from the same laboratory. Students become fluent in the universal language of data analysis as they decipher the figures, interpret the findings, and propose and defend further experiments to test their own hypotheses about the system under study. At the end of the course students gain insight into the individual experiences of article authors by reading authors' responses to an e-mail questionnaire generated by CREATE students. Assessment data indicate that CREATE students gain in ability to read and critically analyze scientific data, as well as in their understanding of, and interest in, research and researchers. The CREATE approach demystifies the process of reading a scientific article and at the same time humanizes scientists. The positive response of students to this method suggests that it could make a significant contribution to retaining undergraduates as science majors.
CREATE(思考、阅读、阐明假设、分析和解释数据以及构思下一个实验)是一种通过原始文献教授科学及科学本质的新方法。CREATE运用一系列独特的新颖教学工具,引导本科生分析期刊文章,通过聚焦同一实验室的四篇文章组成的模块,突出科学思想的演变。学生在解读图表、阐释研究结果并提出和捍卫进一步实验以检验其对所研究系统的假设时,能熟练掌握数据分析这一通用语言。课程结束时,学生通过阅读文章作者对CREATE学生所生成的电子邮件问卷的回复,深入了解文章作者的个人经历。评估数据表明,参与CREATE课程的学生在阅读和批判性分析科学数据的能力方面有所提升,同时在对研究及研究人员的理解和兴趣方面也有所增强。CREATE方法揭开了阅读科学文章过程的神秘面纱,同时使科学家更具人情味。学生对该方法的积极反馈表明,它可能对吸引本科生继续攻读科学专业做出重大贡献。