Ellingson Benjamin M, Ulmer John L, Schmit Brian D
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Marquette University, USA.
Biomed Sci Instrum. 2007;43:128-33.
Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) has been successfully used to image the human brain and spinal cord, although there is still controversy as to which tensor-derived diffusion indices produce the greatest contrast and provide the best anatomical representation of gray and white matter within the spinal cord. The aim of this study was to determine the best diffusion indices for use in the spinal cord using the detectability index, ROC analysis, and opinion data in the form of a survey. DTI of the entire spinal cord (C1-L1) was performed on five neurologically intact human subjects at 1.5-T. Eigenvalues, mean diffusivity (MD), fractional anisotropy (FA), volume ratio (VR), relative anisotropy (RA) and measured anisotropy (deviation of eigenvalues with respect to mean diffusivity) were calculated from the diffusion tensor. ROIs for white matter (WM) and gray matter (GM) were extracted using FA colormaps. The detectability index indicated FA and VR provided significant contrast between GM and WM. Since the FA was used for classification, results appeared to be biased toward FA and indices highly correlated with FA. ROC analysis illustrated similar results, but area under the ROC curve did not show statistical significance between indices. The survey indicated that the deviation of the primary eigenvalue with respect to mean diffusivity (MA1) was significantly better than all other indices at representing underlying spinal cord morphology. This is consistent with previous results showing lack of detail in ventral gray matter regions using the FA. Results indicate FA and MA1 provide the highest contrast and most accurate representation of underlying morphology, respectively.
扩散张量成像(DTI)已成功用于对人类大脑和脊髓进行成像,尽管对于哪些张量衍生的扩散指数能产生最大对比度并能最佳地呈现脊髓内灰质和白质的解剖结构仍存在争议。本研究的目的是使用可检测性指数、ROC分析以及以调查问卷形式收集的意见数据,来确定用于脊髓的最佳扩散指数。对五名神经功能正常的人类受试者在1.5-T条件下对整个脊髓(C1-L1)进行DTI检查。从扩散张量中计算出特征值、平均扩散率(MD)、分数各向异性(FA)、体积比(VR)、相对各向异性(RA)以及测量各向异性(特征值相对于平均扩散率的偏差)。使用FA彩色图提取白质(WM)和灰质(GM)的感兴趣区(ROI)。可检测性指数表明FA和VR在GM和WM之间提供了显著的对比度。由于使用FA进行分类,结果似乎偏向于FA以及与FA高度相关的指数。ROC分析显示了类似的结果,但ROC曲线下面积在各指数之间未显示出统计学意义。调查问卷表明,在表示脊髓潜在形态方面,主特征值相对于平均扩散率的偏差(MA1)明显优于所有其他指数。这与之前使用FA时腹侧灰质区域缺乏细节的结果一致。结果表明,FA和MA1分别提供了最高的对比度和对潜在形态的最准确呈现。