Brahm Nancy C, Gutierres Sheryl L, Carnahan Ryan M
Department of Pharmacy Clinical and Administrative Sciences, University of Oklahoma College of Pharmacy (UOCP), Tulsa, OK 74135-2512, USA.
Am J Health Syst Pharm. 2007 May 15;64(10):1045-53. doi: 10.2146/ajhp060527.
The efficacy and tolerability of quetiapine in the treatment of acute mania were reviewed.
Five randomized, placebo-controlled trials involving quetiapine as monotherapy or adjunct therapy in combination with either divalproex or lithium in the treatment of bipolar mania in either adolescents or adults were identified and reviewed. The primary outcome measure used in the trials was a change in Young Mania Rating Scale total scores. Monotherapy trials evaluated quetiapine, lithium, haloperidol, and placebo. Quetiapine was superior to placebo in both trials. Quetiapine and lithium showed comparable efficacy in one study, though lithium serum concentrations may have been suboptimal. Haloperidol was superior to quetiapine in efficacy at day 21 but similar at day 84. In the two trials evaluating quetiapine or placebo as adjunct therapy to lithium or divalproex, quetiapine was significantly more efficacious than placebo in one trial. In adolescents, quetiapine was more effective than placebo as an adjunct to divalproex. The most common adverse effects clearly attributable to quetiapine in these trials were somnolence and dry mouth. Quetiapine did not induce extrapyramidal effects, but weight gain was notable with the drug.
While quetiapine treatment demonstrated efficacy in the majority of the studies, the robustness of its efficacy is questionable. The use of quetiapine as first-line therapy for acute mania is not recommended based on the available results and cost considerations. However, it may be a useful second-line agent, particularly when sensitivity to extrapyramidal symptoms limits treatment options.
综述喹硫平治疗急性躁狂症的疗效和耐受性。
确定并综述了五项随机、安慰剂对照试验,这些试验涉及喹硫平作为单一疗法或与丙戊酸或锂联合作为辅助疗法,用于治疗青少年或成人的双相躁狂症。试验中使用的主要结局指标是青年躁狂评定量表总分的变化。单一疗法试验评估了喹硫平、锂、氟哌啶醇和安慰剂。在两项试验中,喹硫平均优于安慰剂。在一项研究中,喹硫平和锂显示出相当的疗效,尽管锂的血清浓度可能未达到最佳水平。在第21天时,氟哌啶醇的疗效优于喹硫平,但在第84天时两者相似。在两项评估喹硫平或安慰剂作为锂或丙戊酸辅助疗法的试验中,在一项试验中喹硫平比安慰剂显著更有效。在青少年中,喹硫平作为丙戊酸的辅助药物比安慰剂更有效。在这些试验中,明显归因于喹硫平的最常见不良反应是嗜睡和口干。喹硫平不会诱发锥体外系反应,但该药物会导致明显的体重增加。
虽然喹硫平治疗在大多数研究中显示出疗效,但其疗效的稳健性值得怀疑。基于现有结果和成本考虑,不建议将喹硫平用作急性躁狂症的一线治疗药物。然而,它可能是一种有用的二线药物,特别是当对锥体外系症状的敏感性限制了治疗选择时。