Grivas Theodoros B, Vasiliadis Elias S, Maziotou Christina, Savvidou Olga D
Orthopaedic Department, Thriasio General Hospital, G. Gennimata Av, 19600, Magoula, Attica, Greece.
Scoliosis. 2007 May 14;2:7. doi: 10.1186/1748-7161-2-7.
There is great diversity in the policies for scoliosis screening worldwide. The initial enthusiasm was succeeded by skepticism and the worth of screening programs has been challenged. The criticisms of school screening programs cite mainly the negative psychological impact on children and their families and the increased financial cost of visits and follow-up radiographs. The purpose of this report is to evaluate the direct cost of performing the school screening in a district hospital.
A cost analysis was performed for the estimation of the direct cost of the "Thriasio" school-screening program between January 2000 and May 2006. The analysis involved all the 6470 pupils aged 6-18 years old who were screened at schools for spinal deformities during this period. The factors which were taken into consideration in order to calculate the direct cost of the screening program were a) the number of the examiners b) the working hours, c) the examiners' salary, d) the cost of transportation and finally e) the cost of examination per child.
During the examined period 20 examiners were involved in the program and worked for 1949 working hours. The hourly salary for the trainee doctors was 6.80 euro, for the Health Visitors 6.70 euro and for the Physiotherapists 5.50 euro in current prices. The cost of transportation was 32 euro per year. The direct cost for the examination of each child for the above studied period was calculated to be 2.04 euro.
The cost of our school-screening program is low. The present study provides a strong evidence for the continuation of the program when looking from a financial point of view.
全球脊柱侧弯筛查政策存在很大差异。最初的热情之后是怀疑,筛查项目的价值受到了挑战。对学校筛查项目的批评主要集中在对儿童及其家庭的负面心理影响以及就诊和后续X光检查增加的经济成本。本报告的目的是评估在一家区级医院进行学校筛查的直接成本。
对2000年1月至2006年5月期间“Thriasio”学校筛查项目的直接成本进行了成本分析。该分析涉及在此期间在学校接受脊柱畸形筛查的所有6470名6至18岁的学生。为计算筛查项目的直接成本而考虑的因素有:a)检查人员数量;b)工作时间;c)检查人员工资;d)交通成本;最后e)每个孩子的检查成本。
在检查期间,有20名检查人员参与该项目,工作时长为1949小时。按当前价格计算,实习医生的时薪为6.80欧元,健康访视员为6.70欧元,物理治疗师为5.50欧元。交通成本为每年32欧元。上述研究期间每个孩子的检查直接成本计算为2.04欧元。
我们学校筛查项目的成本较低。从财务角度来看,本研究为该项目的持续开展提供了有力证据。