Sabatino Susan A, Coates Ralph J, Uhler Robert J, Pollack Lori A, Alley Linda G, Zauderer Laura J
Division of Cancer Prevention and Control, National Centers for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA30341, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2007 May 20;25(15):2100-6. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2006.06.6340.
To examine provider discussion or counseling of US cancer survivors about diet, exercise, and tobacco use.
We used 2000 National Health Interview Survey data to examine whether US cancer survivors reported that, within 1 year, a provider (1) discussed diet, (2) recommended they begin or continue exercise, or (3) asked about smoking. We included survivors more than 1 year beyond diagnosis (n = 1,600) and adults without cancer (AWCs; n = 24,636) who saw/talked to a provider within 1 year. We used generalized linear contrasts in bivariable analyses and logistic regression to calculate predicted marginals adjusted for age, sex, comorbidity, usual source of care, and number of provider visits in the prior year.
Few survivors reported discussions or recommendations for all three health behaviors (10% of survivors v 9% of AWCs; P = .57). Although report was more likely than among AWCs, few survivors reported diet discussions (30% of survivors v 23% of AWCs; P < .0001) or exercise recommendations (26% of survivors v 23% of AWCs; P < .005), and a minority were asked about smoking (42% of survivors v 41% of AWCs; P = .41). After adjustment, survivors were less likely to report exercise recommendations than were AWCs (22% v 24%, respectively; P = .02). Colorectal cancer survivors were less likely than were AWCs of similar age range to report exercise recommendations (16% v 27%, respectively; P < .003) or smoking discussions (31% v 41%, respectively; P < .05). Cervical cancer survivors were more likely than AWCs of similar age range to discuss smoking (58% v 43%, respectively; P < .001).
Findings from this nationally representative sample suggest that many providers may miss opportunities to counsel survivors about healthy behaviors, perhaps particularly colorectal cancer survivors.
研究美国癌症幸存者的医疗服务提供者是否就饮食、运动和烟草使用问题与他们进行过讨论或提供咨询。
我们使用了2000年全国健康访谈调查数据,以研究美国癌症幸存者是否报告称,在1年内,医疗服务提供者(1)讨论过饮食,(2)建议他们开始或继续运动,或(3)询问过吸烟情况。我们纳入了诊断后超过1年的幸存者(n = 1600)以及在1年内看过/与医疗服务提供者交谈过的无癌症成年人(AWC;n = 24636)。我们在双变量分析中使用广义线性对比,并采用逻辑回归来计算经年龄、性别、合并症、通常的医疗服务来源以及上一年医疗服务提供者就诊次数调整后的预测边际值。
很少有幸存者报告就所有三种健康行为都进行过讨论或得到过建议(10%的幸存者对9%的AWC;P = 0.57)。尽管幸存者比AWC更有可能报告相关情况,但很少有幸存者报告过饮食讨论(30%的幸存者对23%的AWC;P < 0.0001)或运动建议(26%的幸存者对23%的AWC;P < 0.005),只有少数人被询问过吸烟情况(42%的幸存者对41%的AWC;P = 0.41)。调整后,幸存者报告得到运动建议的可能性低于AWC(分别为22%和24%;P = 0.02)。结直肠癌幸存者比年龄范围相似的AWC报告得到运动建议(分别为16%和27%;P < 0.003)或吸烟讨论(分别为31%和41%;P < 0.05)的可能性更低。宫颈癌幸存者比年龄范围相似的AWC讨论吸烟问题的可能性更高(分别为58%和43%;P < 0.001)。
来自这个具有全国代表性样本的研究结果表明,许多医疗服务提供者可能错失了就健康行为向幸存者提供咨询的机会,结直肠癌幸存者可能尤其如此。