Sunderland Alan, Shinner Caroline
School of Psychology, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK.
Cortex. 2007 Apr;43(3):359-67. doi: 10.1016/s0010-9452(08)70461-1.
The impact of ideomotor apraxia (IMA) on functional ability has been a relatively neglected topic in research. This has been due to the continued focus on performance on gesture imitation and pantomime of tool-use, together with widespread acceptance of anecdotal evidence that IMA has no effect when directly manipulating objects. An increasing number of studies have shown that IMA does in fact result in increased clumsiness when handling objects and may contribute to disability in everyday life. However the effect seems relatively mild compared to the stark abnormalities on gesture imitation and pantomime. The conventional explanation for this is that the cues provided by naturalistic contexts improve retrieval of action representations, but an alternative account concerns task-specific cognitive demands. Performance on simple prehensile tasks can be successfully guided by physical affordances whereas motor tasks may be failed if they require the support of memory or problem solving ability. A central deficit in IMA may be impaired postural representation causing inability to solve the problem of how to manipulate objects where neither affordance nor memory can dictate action. However, this account still fails to explain fully the patterns of error seen on complex naturalistic tasks such as dressing. Future research needs to further our understanding of how IMA maps on to disability, which will have implications for theory building and for therapeutic intervention.
观念运动性失用症(IMA)对功能能力的影响在研究中一直是一个相对被忽视的话题。这是由于研究持续聚焦于手势模仿和工具使用的哑剧表演的表现,同时人们普遍接受轶事证据,即IMA在直接操纵物体时没有影响。越来越多的研究表明,IMA实际上确实会导致在处理物体时笨拙程度增加,并可能导致日常生活中的残疾。然而,与手势模仿和哑剧表演中明显的异常相比,这种影响似乎相对较轻。对此的传统解释是,自然情境提供的线索改善了动作表征的检索,但另一种解释涉及特定任务的认知需求。简单的抓握任务的表现可以由物理可供性成功引导,而运动任务如果需要记忆或解决问题能力的支持可能会失败。IMA的一个核心缺陷可能是姿势表征受损,导致在既没有可供性也没有记忆可以指导动作的情况下,无法解决如何操纵物体的问题。然而,这种解释仍然无法完全解释在诸如穿衣等复杂自然情境任务中出现的错误模式。未来的研究需要进一步加深我们对IMA如何导致残疾的理解,这将对理论构建和治疗干预产生影响。