Jacob Benjamin G, Muturi Ephantus J, Mwangangi Joseph M, Funes Jose, Caamano Erick X, Muriu Simon, Shililu Josephat, Githure John, Novak Robert J
Illinois Natural History Survey, Center for Ecological Entomology, Champaign, Illinois 61820, USA.
Int J Health Geogr. 2007 Jun 5;6:21. doi: 10.1186/1476-072X-6-21.
We examined algorithms for malaria mapping using the impact of reflectance calibration uncertainties on the accuracies of three vegetation indices (VI)'s derived from QuickBird data in three rice agro-village complexes Mwea, Kenya. We also generated inferential statistics from field sampled vegetation covariates for identifying riceland Anopheles arabiensis during the crop season. All aquatic habitats in the study sites were stratified based on levels of rice stages; flooded, land preparation, post-transplanting, tillering, flowering/maturation and post-harvest/fallow. A set of uncertainty propagation equations were designed to model the propagation of calibration uncertainties using the red channel (band 3: 0.63 to 0.69 microm) and the near infra-red (NIR) channel (band 4: 0.76 to 0.90 microm) to generate the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and the Soil Adjusted Vegetation Index (SAVI). The Atmospheric Resistant Vegetation Index (ARVI) was also evaluated incorporating the QuickBird blue band (Band 1: 0.45 to 0.52 microm) to normalize atmospheric effects. In order to determine local clustering of riceland habitats Gi*(d) statistics were generated from the ground-based and remotely-sensed ecological databases. Additionally, all riceland habitats were visually examined using the spectral reflectance of vegetation land cover for identification of highly productive riceland Anopheles oviposition sites.
The resultant VI uncertainties did not vary from surface reflectance or atmospheric conditions. Logistic regression analyses of all field sampled covariates revealed emergent vegetation was negatively associated with mosquito larvae at the three study sites. In addition, floating vegetation (-ve) was significantly associated with immature mosquitoes in Rurumi and Kiuria (-ve); while, turbidity was also important in Kiuria. All spatial models exhibit positive autocorrelation; similar numbers of log-counts tend to cluster in geographic space. The spectral reflectance from riceland habitats, examined using the remote and field stratification, revealed post-transplanting and tillering rice stages were most frequently associated with high larval abundance and distribution.
NDVI, SAVI and ARVI generated from QuickBird data and field sampled vegetation covariates modeled cannot identify highly productive riceland An. arabiensis aquatic habitats. However, combining spectral reflectance of riceland habitats from QuickBird and field sampled data can develop and implement an Integrated Vector Management (IVM) program based on larval productivity.
我们在肯尼亚姆韦亚的三个水稻农业村庄综合体中,研究了利用反射率校准不确定性对从快鸟数据得出的三种植被指数(VI)精度的影响来绘制疟疾地图的算法。我们还从实地采样的植被协变量中生成了推断统计数据,以在作物季节识别稻田中的阿拉伯按蚊。研究地点的所有水生栖息地都根据水稻生长阶段进行了分层;淹水期、整地期、移栽后期、分蘖期、开花/成熟期和收获后/休耕期。设计了一组不确定性传播方程,以利用红色通道(波段3:0.63至0.69微米)和近红外(NIR)通道(波段4:0.76至0.90微米)对校准不确定性的传播进行建模,以生成归一化差异植被指数(NDVI)和土壤调整植被指数(SAVI)。还纳入快鸟蓝色波段(波段1:0.45至0.52微米)对大气抗性植被指数(ARVI)进行了评估,以归一化大气影响。为了确定稻田栖息地的局部聚类,从地面和遥感生态数据库中生成了Gi*(d)统计量。此外,利用植被土地覆盖的光谱反射率对所有稻田栖息地进行了目视检查,以识别高产稻田中按蚊的产卵地点。
所得的植被指数不确定性与表面反射率或大气条件无关。对所有实地采样协变量的逻辑回归分析表明,在三个研究地点,新生植被与蚊虫幼虫呈负相关。此外,漂浮植被(-ve)与鲁鲁米和基乌里亚的未成熟蚊虫显著相关(-ve);同时,浊度在基乌里亚也很重要。所有空间模型均表现出正自相关;相似数量的对数计数倾向于在地理空间中聚类。利用遥感和实地分层对稻田栖息地的光谱反射率进行检查,结果表明移栽后和分蘖期的水稻生长阶段与幼虫的高丰度和分布最为相关。
从快鸟数据和实地采样的植被协变量模型生成的NDVI、SAVI和ARVI无法识别高产稻田中的阿拉伯按蚊水生栖息地。然而,结合快鸟数据和实地采样数据中稻田栖息地的光谱反射率,可以制定并实施基于幼虫生产力的综合病媒管理(IVM)计划。