Kemper Kathi J, Gardiner Paula, Woods Charles
Department of Pediatrics, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, USA.
BMC Complement Altern Med. 2007 Jun 12;7:21. doi: 10.1186/1472-6882-7-21.
Little is known about clinicians' use of herbs and dietary supplements (HDS), how their personal HDS use changes with time and training, and how changes in their personal use affect their confidence or communication with patients about HDS.
We conducted a prospective cohort study of clinicians before and after an on-line curriculum about HDS in winter-spring, 2005.
Of the 569 clinicians who completed surveys both at baseline and after the course, 25% were male and the average age was 42 years old; 88% used HDS before and after the course. The average number of supplements used fell slightly from 6.2 at baseline to 5.8 after the course (P < 0.01). The most commonly used supplements at baseline were: multivitamins (65%), calcium (42%), B vitamins (34%), vitamin C (34%), green tea (27%), fish oil (27%) and vitamin E (25%). Use of fish oil increased to 30% after the course (P = 0.01). Use of supplements traditionally used to treat colds decreased: vitamin C (34% to 27%), zinc (13% to 10%), and echinacea (7% to 5%, P < 0.05 for all three). Changes in personal HDS use were not associated with significant changes in confidence or communication with patients.
Many clinicians use HDS personally; use changes seasonally and to a small extent with professional education. Professional use of HDS is dynamic and seasonal. Additional research is needed to understand the impact of personal use on professional attitudes and behavior in populations with lower baseline uses of HDS.
对于临床医生使用草药和膳食补充剂(HDS)的情况、他们个人使用HDS的情况如何随时间和培训而变化,以及他们个人使用情况的变化如何影响其对HDS的信心或与患者的沟通,我们知之甚少。
我们在2005年冬春季节对临床医生进行了一项关于HDS的在线课程前后的前瞻性队列研究。
在569名在基线和课程结束后都完成调查的临床医生中,25%为男性,平均年龄为42岁;88%在课程前后都使用HDS。使用的补充剂平均数量从基线时的6.2种略有下降至课程结束后的5.8种(P < 0.01)。基线时最常用的补充剂为:多种维生素(65%)、钙(42%)、B族维生素(34%)、维生素C(34%)、绿茶(27%)、鱼油(27%)和维生素E(25%)。课程结束后鱼油的使用增加至30%(P = 0.01)。传统上用于治疗感冒的补充剂的使用减少:维生素C(从34%降至27%)、锌(从13%降至10%)和紫锥菊(从7%降至5%,所有三项P < 0.05)。个人使用HDS的变化与对患者的信心或沟通的显著变化无关。
许多临床医生个人使用HDS;使用情况随季节变化,并且在一定程度上随专业教育而变化。HDS的专业使用是动态的且随季节变化。需要进一步研究以了解个人使用对HDS基线使用较低人群的专业态度和行为的影响。