Chen Fei, Wang Bin, Chen Lu-zeng
Department of Diagnostic Ultrasound, Peking University First Hospital, Beijing 100034, China.
Zhonghua Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2007 Mar 27;87(12):823-5.
To compare safety and sensitivity in diagnosis of liver lesion between ultrasound-guided 16 gauges (G) and 18 G core needle biopsy.
Ultrasound-guided 16 G needle biopsy was performed in 141 patients, 77 males and 64e females, aged 51.2, and ultrasound-guided 18 G needle biopsy was performed in 105 patients, 54 males and 51 females, aged 60.1. The final diagnosis was based on the post-operative pathological examination and/or the results of 6-month follow-up.
In the In the ultrasound-guided 16 G needle biopsy, 171 passes were performed with an average of 1.21 pass, a sensitivity rate of 95.9%, and a specificity rate of 100%, and abdominal pain occurred in 51 cases, and bleeding occurred in 3 cases. In the ultrasound-guided 18 G needle biopsy, 161 passes were performed with an average of 1.53 passes, a sensitivity rate of 83.8%, and a specificity rate of 100%, and abdominal pain occurred in 37 cases, and bleeding occurred in 2 cases. The number of pass of the 16 G was significantly less then that of the 128 G group (P = 0.000). The sensitivity rate of the 16 G needle biopsy was significantly higher than that of the 18 G group (P = 0.46).
Ultrasound-guided 16 gauges core needle biopsy is safe for the diagnosis of hepatic disease and more sensitive than the 18 G biopsy.
比较超声引导下16号(G)与18G粗针活检诊断肝脏病变的安全性和敏感性。
对141例患者进行超声引导下16G针活检,其中男性77例,女性64例,年龄51.2岁;对105例患者进行超声引导下18G针活检,其中男性54例,女性51例,年龄60.1岁。最终诊断基于术后病理检查和/或6个月随访结果。
在超声引导下16G针活检中,进针171次,平均1.21次,敏感率95.9%,特异率100%,51例出现腹痛,3例发生出血。在超声引导下18G针活检中,进针161次,平均1.53次,敏感率83.8%,特异率100%,37例出现腹痛,2例发生出血。16G组进针次数显著少于18G组(P = 0.000)。16G针活检的敏感率显著高于18G组(P = 0.46)。
超声引导下16G粗针活检对肝脏疾病的诊断安全,且比18G活检更敏感。