Billis Evdokia V, McCarthy Christopher J, Oldham Jacqueline A
Department of Physiotherapy, Technological Educational Institute (TEI) of Lamia, Lamia, Fthiotida, Greece.
Eur Spine J. 2007 Jul;16(7):865-79. doi: 10.1007/s00586-007-0313-2. Epub 2007 Mar 17.
Various health professionals have attempted to classify low back pain (LBP) subgroups and have developed several LBP classification systems. Knowing that culture has an effect on LBP symptomatology, assessment findings and clinical decision making, the aim of this review is to perform a cross-country comparative review amongst the published classification systems, addressing each country's similarities and differences as well as exploring whether cultural factors have been incorporated into the subclassification process. A systematic search of databases limited to human adults was undertaken by Medline, Cinahl, AMED and PEDro databases between January 1980 and October 2005. Classification systems from nine countries were identified. Most studies were classified according to pathoanatomic and/or clinical features, whereas fewer studies utilized a psychosocial and even less, a biopsychosocial approach. Most studies were limited in use to the country of the system's developer. Very few studies addressed cultural issues, highlighting the lack of information on the impact of specific cultural factors on LBP classification procedures. However, there seem to be certain 'cultural trends' in classification systems within each country, which are discussed. Despite the plethora of classification studies, there is still no system which is internationally established, effective, reliable and valid. Future research should aim to develop a LBP classification system within a well identified cultural setting, addressing the multi-dimensional features of the LBP presentation.
众多医疗专业人员尝试对下背痛(LBP)亚组进行分类,并开发了多种LBP分类系统。鉴于文化会对LBP症状学、评估结果及临床决策产生影响,本综述旨在对已发表的分类系统进行跨国比较,探讨各国之间的异同,以及研究文化因素是否已纳入亚分类过程。通过对Medline、Cinahl、AMED和PEDro数据库在1980年1月至2005年10月期间进行系统检索,检索仅限于成年人类的数据库。共识别出九个国家的分类系统。大多数研究是根据病理解剖和/或临床特征进行分类的,而采用社会心理方法的研究较少,采用生物心理社会方法的研究更少。大多数研究的应用仅限于系统开发者所在的国家。很少有研究涉及文化问题,这凸显了关于特定文化因素对LBP分类程序影响的信息匮乏。然而,每个国家的分类系统中似乎都存在某些“文化趋势”,本文对此进行了讨论。尽管有大量的分类研究,但仍没有一个在国际上得到确立、有效、可靠且适用的系统。未来的研究应致力于在明确的文化背景下开发一个LBP分类系统,以应对LBP表现的多维度特征。