Nicotera Nicole
Graduate School of Social Work, University of Denver, 2148 South High Street, Denver, CO 80208, USA.
Am J Community Psychol. 2007 Sep;40(1-2):26-51. doi: 10.1007/s10464-007-9124-1.
This article contributes to the knowledge base of neighborhood intervention and research by reviewing the myriad ways the construct neighborhood is operationalized. The interdisciplinary review presents a critical examination of each measurement genre from quantitative to qualitative. The discussion of neighborhood measures includes (a) census and other administrative data, (b) windshield surveys, (c) rating scales, (d) structured/unstructured interviews (including ethnographies), (e) residents' written descriptions, (f) photographs, (g) drawings, and (h) mixed method constructions. When pertinent, the role of children's voices in these measures is discussed. In addition, the conceptual nature of neighborhood is examined from the perspective of environment and place. This environment-place duality is presented as a framework for choosing the type of measure one plans to use for research or practice. Conclusions suggest that research and practice are enhanced by building bridges between measures representing environment and measures representing place. Such bridges offer opportunities to develop interventions that are viable for creating lasting change.
本文通过回顾邻里概念得以实施的众多方式,为邻里干预和研究的知识库做出了贡献。这一跨学科综述对从定量到定性的每种测量类型进行了批判性审视。邻里测量的讨论包括:(a)人口普查和其他行政数据;(b)挡风玻璃调查;(c)评级量表;(d)结构化/非结构化访谈(包括人种志);(e)居民的书面描述;(f)照片;(g)绘图;以及(h)混合方法构建。在相关情况下,还讨论了儿童声音在这些测量中的作用。此外,从环境和场所的角度审视了邻里的概念本质。这种环境 - 场所二元性被作为一个框架,用于选择计划用于研究或实践的测量类型。结论表明,通过在代表环境的测量和代表场所的测量之间架起桥梁,可以加强研究和实践。这样的桥梁为开发能够产生持久变化的可行干预措施提供了机会。