Gaffney Shannon H, Paustenbach Dennis J
ChemRisk, Inc., 25 Jessie Street, Suite 1800; San Francisco, CA 94105, USA.
Ann Occup Hyg. 2007 Jun;51(4):345-56. doi: 10.1093/annhyg/mem019. Epub 2007 Jun 30.
Setting occupational exposure limits (OELs) for odorous or irritating chemicals is a global occupational health challenge. However, often there is inadequate knowledge about the toxicology of these chemicals to set an OEL and their irritation potencies are usually not recognized until they are manufactured or used in large quantities.
In this paper, the importance of accounting for risk perception and communication; conditioned responses; and interindividual variability in tolerance, detection and susceptibility with respect to setting an OEL are discussed in relation to three chemosensory models. These parameters and models were then used to construct a flowchart-style methodology that can be used to set an OEL for a specific chemical.
The OEL identified for a chemical odorant or irritant will depend on the type of chemosensory effect that the chemical is likely to exhibit. For example, experience has shown that chemicals with a low odor threshold often require low OELs even though many are not toxic or do not cause irritation at those air concentrations.
In order to establish the appropriate OEL, organizations need to agree upon the percentage of the workforce that they are attempting to protect and the types of toxicological end points that are sufficiently important to protect against (e.g. transient eye irritation, enzyme induction or other reversible effects). This is particularly true for sensory irritants. The method described in this paper could also be extended to setting limits for ambient air contaminants where risk perception plays a dominant role in whether the public views the exposure as being reasonable or safe.
为有气味或刺激性的化学品设定职业接触限值(OELs)是一项全球性的职业健康挑战。然而,对于这些化学品的毒理学知识往往不足,难以设定OELs,而且在大量生产或使用之前,它们的刺激强度通常未被认识到。
本文结合三种化学感官模型,讨论了在设定OELs时考虑风险认知与沟通、条件反应以及个体在耐受性、检测和易感性方面的个体差异的重要性。然后使用这些参数和模型构建了一种流程图式的方法,可用于为特定化学品设定OELs。
为化学气味剂或刺激物确定的OELs将取决于该化学品可能表现出的化学感官效应类型。例如,经验表明,气味阈值低的化学品通常需要较低的OELs,尽管许多在那些空气浓度下无毒或不会引起刺激。
为了确定适当的OELs,各组织需要就其试图保护的劳动力比例以及足以防止的毒理学终点类型(如短暂的眼部刺激、酶诱导或其他可逆效应)达成一致。对于感官刺激物尤其如此。本文所述方法也可扩展到设定环境空气污染物限值,在这种情况下,风险认知在公众是否认为接触合理或安全方面起着主导作用。