Cummings J E, Weaver F M
Edward Hines, Jr. VA Hospital, Hines, Illinois.
Clin Geriatr Med. 1991 Nov;7(4):865-74.
Home health care is uniformly accepted by patients, caregivers, health professionals, policymakers, and the public as a desirable way to provide care to disabled individuals and the frail elderly. Given the lack of positive impact of home care upon functional status, cost, and nursing home use, as well as documented additional cost, future research must focus upon positive aspects from past experiences. Careful targeting of patients most likely to benefit from this care has produced better results. Satisfaction with care has been shown consistently. Managed home health care may have the potential, especially the impact of physician involvement with team care on hospital use, to contain costs. The intuitive belief that home care is beneficial and a worthwhile expense, held by policymakers and health care professionals alike, needs to be fully researched by studies that carefully examine the wide spectrum of home care benefits for disabled or chronically ill individuals in relation to varying cost levels that the population and health care system can absorb. The challenge is here, and those who believe in home care need to make use of the results of these previous, rather nonsupportive studies. Additional research is needed to measure the impact of active physician participation in the team care provision of home care services and the impact of managed home care on the cost of hospital care in the population most at risk for recurrent hospitalization. This same research must document not only more effective targeting of individuals, but also the maintenance of increased satisfaction with care--strongest motive for the need to prove the cost-effectiveness of home care.
家庭医疗保健被患者、护理人员、医疗专业人员、政策制定者和公众一致认为是为残疾人和体弱老年人提供护理的理想方式。鉴于家庭护理对功能状态、成本和养老院使用缺乏积极影响,以及记录在案的额外成本,未来的研究必须关注过去经验中的积极方面。对最有可能从这种护理中受益的患者进行精准定位已产生了更好的效果。对护理的满意度一直都有体现。管理式家庭医疗保健可能有潜力控制成本,尤其是医生参与团队护理对医院使用的影响。政策制定者和医疗保健专业人员都直觉地认为家庭护理是有益的且是一项值得的开支,但需要通过研究进行全面调查,这些研究要仔细审视针对残疾或慢性病患者的广泛家庭护理益处,以及人口和医疗保健系统能够承受的不同成本水平。挑战就在这里,那些相信家庭护理的人需要利用这些先前不太支持的研究结果。还需要进行更多研究,以衡量医生积极参与家庭护理服务的团队提供所产生的影响,以及管理式家庭护理对最易再次住院人群的医院护理成本的影响。同样,这项研究不仅必须记录对个体更有效的定位,还必须记录护理满意度的持续提高——这是证明家庭护理成本效益必要性的最强烈动机。