Forsby Anna, Blaauboer Bas
Department of Neurochemistry, Svante Arrhenius Laboratories for Natural Sciences, Stockholm University, Stockholm, Sweden.
Hum Exp Toxicol. 2007 Apr;26(4):333-8. doi: 10.1177/0960327106072994.
Risk assessment of neurotoxicity is mainly based on in vivo exposure, followed by tests on behaviour, physiology and pathology. In this study, an attempt to estimate lowest observed neurotoxic doses after single or repeated dose exposure was performed. Differentiated human neuroblastoma SH-SY5Y cells were exposed to acrylamide, lindane, parathion, paraoxon, phenytoin, diazepam or caffeine for 72 hours. The effects on protein synthesis and intracellular free Ca2+ concentration were studied as physiological endpoints. Voltage operated Ca2+ channel function, acetylcholine receptor function and neurite degenerative effects were investigated as neurospecific endpoints for excitability, cholinergic signal transduction and axonopathy, respectively. The general cytotoxicity, determined as the total cellular protein levels after the 72 hours exposure period, was used for comparison to the specific endpoints and for estimation of acute lethality. The lowest concentration that induced 20% effect (EC20) obtained for each compound, was used as a surrogate for the lowest neurotoxic level (LOEL) at the target site in vivo. The LOELs were integrated with data on adsorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion of the compounds in physiologically-based biokinetic (PBBK) models of the rat and the lowest observed effective doses (LOEDs) were estimated for the test compounds. A good correlation was observed between the estimated LOEDs and experimental LOEDs found in literature for rat for all test compounds, except for diazepam. However, when using in vitro data from the literature on diazepam's effect on gamma-amino butyric acid (GABA)A receptor function for the estimation of LOED, the correlation between the estimated and experimental LOEDs was improved from a 10,000-fold to a 10-fold difference. Our results indicate that it is possible to estimate LOEDs by integrating in vitro toxicity data as surrogates for lowest observed target tissue levels with PBBK models, provided that some knowledge about toxic mechanisms is known.
神经毒性的风险评估主要基于体内暴露情况,随后进行行为、生理和病理学测试。在本研究中,尝试估算单次或重复剂量暴露后的最低观察到的神经毒性剂量。将分化的人神经母细胞瘤SH-SY5Y细胞暴露于丙烯酰胺、林丹、对硫磷、对氧磷、苯妥英、地西泮或咖啡因72小时。研究了对蛋白质合成和细胞内游离钙离子浓度的影响作为生理终点。分别研究了电压门控钙离子通道功能、乙酰胆碱受体功能和神经突退化效应作为兴奋性、胆碱能信号转导和轴索性病变的神经特异性终点。将72小时暴露期后的总细胞蛋白水平确定的一般细胞毒性用于与特定终点进行比较,并用于估计急性致死率。每种化合物获得的诱导20%效应的最低浓度(EC20)用作体内靶位点最低神经毒性水平(LOEL)的替代指标。将LOEL与大鼠基于生理的生物动力学(PBBK)模型中化合物的吸附、分布、代谢和排泄数据相结合,估算测试化合物的最低观察到的有效剂量(LOED)。除地西泮外,所有测试化合物的估算LOED与文献中大鼠实验性LOED之间均观察到良好的相关性。然而,当使用文献中关于地西泮对γ-氨基丁酸(GABA)A受体功能影响的体外数据来估算LOED时,估算的和实验性LOED之间的相关性从10000倍差异提高到了10倍差异。我们的结果表明,只要了解一些毒性机制,就有可能通过将体外毒性数据作为最低观察到的靶组织水平的替代指标与PBBK模型相结合来估算LOED。