Doren Dennis M, Yates Pamela M
Sand Ridge Secure Treatment Center, Madison, WI 53704, USA.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2008 Apr;52(2):234-45. doi: 10.1177/0306624X07303914. Epub 2007 Jul 5.
Meta-analyses have suggested that sexual offender treatment (SOT) completion is associated with lowered sexual recidivism rates for convicted sexual offenders. The paucity of properly designed studies allows for the alternative explanation of less recidivism among treated samples as reflecting that lower risk offenders disproportionately self-select into treatment. A test of the "self-selection explanation" can occur by investigating treatment effect on known high-risk offenders. Psychopathy correlates with increased sexual recidivism risk, such that an exploration of the SOT effect on psychopathic offenders could clarify the accuracy of the self-selection hypothesis. Additionally, the debated degree to which psychopaths are treatable might obtain clarification by a research review. This article examines empirical findings concerning the effectiveness of SOT for psychopathic sexual offenders. Ten studies were found to meet the minimal quality standards used, stemming from only four data sources. Shortcomings of existing research precluded clear conclusions, though trends in the data are delineated.
元分析表明,性犯罪者治疗(SOT)的完成与已定罪性犯罪者性再犯率的降低有关。设计合理的研究数量稀少,这使得另一种解释成为可能,即接受治疗样本中再犯率较低反映出低风险犯罪者不成比例地自行选择接受治疗。通过调查对已知高风险犯罪者的治疗效果,可以对“自我选择解释”进行检验。心理变态与性再犯风险增加相关,因此对心理变态犯罪者的SOT效果进行探索可以阐明自我选择假设的准确性。此外,通过研究综述可能会澄清关于心理变态者可治疗程度的争议。本文考察了关于SOT对心理变态性犯罪者有效性的实证研究结果。发现有十项研究符合所使用的最低质量标准,这些研究仅来自四个数据源。现有研究的缺点妨碍了得出明确结论,不过数据中的趋势已作了描述。