Cobo E R, Favetto P H, Lane V M, Friend A, VanHooser K, Mitchell J, BonDurant R H
Department of Population Health and Reproduction, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA.
Theriogenology. 2007 Oct 1;68(6):853-60. doi: 10.1016/j.theriogenology.2007.06.019. Epub 2007 Aug 6.
The sensitivity (Se) and specificity (Sp) of different testing schemes were estimated for detecting Tritrichomonas foetus (T. foetus) in smegma samples from experimentally infected bulls. Culture and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) on smegma samples were evaluated alone and in parallel testing. Mature dairy bulls (n=79) were intrapreputially inoculated with T. foetus (n=19); Campylobacter (C.) fetus venerealis (n=13); both T. foetus and C. fetus venerealis (n=11); Tetratrichomonas spp. (n=9); C. fetus fetus (n=8); or were not inoculated (n=19). For each bull, smegma samples were collected for 6 week post-inoculation and tested for T. foetus by In Pouch TF culture and PCR. Most T. foetus-inoculated bulls became infected, according to culture (86.7%), PCR (90.0%), and both tests together (93.3%). In T. foetus-inoculated bulls, both tests combined in parallel on a single sample had a Se (78.3%) and Sp (98.5%) similar to two cultures (Se 76.0%, Sp 98.5%) or two PCR (Se 78.0%, Sp 96.7%) sampled on consecutive weeks. The PCR on three consecutive weekly samples (Se 85.0%, Sp 95.4%) and both tests applied in parallel on three consecutive weekly samples (Se 87.5%, Sp 95.6%) were similar to the current gold-standard of six weekly cultures (Se 86.7% and Sp 97.5%). Both tests used in parallel six times had the highest Se (93.3%), with similar Sp (92.5%). Tetratrichomonas spp. were only sporadically detected by culture or PCR. In conclusion, we have proposed alternative strategies for T. foetus diagnostics (for the AI industry), including a combination of tests and repeat testing strategies that may reduce time and cost for bull surveillance.
为检测实验感染公牛包皮垢样本中的胎儿三毛滴虫(T. foetus),评估了不同检测方案的敏感性(Se)和特异性(Sp)。对包皮垢样本单独及平行进行培养和聚合酶链反应(PCR)检测。选取成熟奶牛公牛(n = 79),经包皮内接种胎儿三毛滴虫(n = 19)、性病胎儿弯曲杆菌(C. fetus venerealis,n = 13)、胎儿三毛滴虫和性病胎儿弯曲杆菌(n = 11)、四毛滴虫属(Tetratrichomonas spp.,n = 9)、胎儿弯曲杆菌(C. fetus fetus,n = 8),或不进行接种(n = 19)。对每头公牛,在接种后6周采集包皮垢样本,通过In Pouch TF培养和PCR检测胎儿三毛滴虫。根据培养(86.7%)、PCR(90.0%)以及两种检测方法联合检测(93.3%)结果,大多数接种胎儿三毛滴虫的公牛被感染。在接种胎儿三毛滴虫的公牛中,对单个样本进行两种检测方法平行联合检测的Se(78.3%)和Sp(98.5%),与连续两周进行两次培养(Se 76.0%,Sp 98.5%)或两次PCR(Se 78.0%,Sp 96.7%)检测的结果相似。连续三周每周样本进行PCR检测(Se 85.0%,Sp 95.4%)以及连续三周每周样本进行两种检测方法平行联合检测(Se 87.5%,Sp 95.6%),与当前六周每周进行培养的金标准检测结果(Se 86.7%,Sp 97.5%)相似。两种检测方法平行进行六次检测时Se最高(93.3%),Sp相似(92.5%)。通过培养或PCR仅偶尔检测到四毛滴虫属。总之,我们为胎儿三毛滴虫诊断(针对人工授精行业)提出了替代策略,包括联合检测和重复检测策略,这可能会减少公牛监测的时间和成本。