McLoughlin Pauline, Warin Megan
Discipline of Gender, Work and Social Inquiry, School of Humanities and Social Sciences, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, SA, Australia.
Health Place. 2008 Jun;14(2):254-64. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2007.06.008. Epub 2007 Jul 10.
Since their establishment in 1992, Australian Immigration Detention Centres have been the focus of increasing concern due to allegations of their serious impact on the mental health of asylum seekers. Informed by Foucault's treatise on surveillance and the phenomenological work of Casey, this paper extends the current clinical data by examining the architecture and location of detention centres, and the complex relationships between space, place and mental health. In spatialising these relationships, we argue that Immigration Detention Centres operate not only as Panopticons, but are embodied by asylum seekers as 'anti-places': as places that mediate and constitute thinned out and liminal experiences. In particular, it is the embodied effects of surveillance and suspended liminality that impact on mental health. An approach which locates the embodiment of place and space as central to the poor mental health of asylum seekers adds an important dimension to our understandings of (dis)placement and mental health in the lives of the exiled.
自1992年成立以来,澳大利亚移民拘留中心因其被指控对寻求庇护者的心理健康产生严重影响而日益受到关注。本文以福柯关于监视的论述和凯西的现象学著作作为参考,通过考察拘留中心的建筑结构和位置,以及空间、场所与心理健康之间的复杂关系,扩展了当前的临床数据。在将这些关系空间化的过程中,我们认为移民拘留中心不仅作为全景敞视监狱运作,而且被寻求庇护者具体体验为“反场所”:作为调解并构成稀薄且处于阈限状态体验的场所。特别是,监视和悬置的阈限状态的具体影响对心理健康产生了冲击。一种将场所和空间的具体体验视为寻求庇护者心理健康不佳的核心因素的方法,为我们理解流亡者生活中的(流离失所)和心理健康增添了一个重要维度。