Sørensen P S, Larsen B H, Rasmussen M J, Kinge E, Iversen H, Alslev T, Nøhr P, Pedersen K K, Schrøder P, Lademann A
Department of Neurology, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Headache. 1991 Nov;31(10):650-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.1991.hed3110650.x.
The prophylactic effect of flunarizine and metoprolol was studied in a multi-center randomized, double-blind trial of 149 patients with migraine with or without aura. After a 4-week placebo run-in period, patients were randomly allocated to treatment with flunarizine 10 mg daily or metoprolol 200 mg daily for 16 weeks (parallel group design). Both drugs reduced the number of migraine days per month by 37% (95% confidence interval 21-53%) compared with the placebo run-in period. All efficacy parameters were significantly reduced by both drugs and no significant difference was found between the two drugs at any time of the treatment period. However, calculation of the 95% confidence limits showed that each drug may have a superiority of more than 100% on a single main effect parameter. The most common adverse experiences were day-time sedation (both drugs) and weight gain (flunarizine). Depression was the most serious side-effect occurring in 8% on flunarizine and 3% on metoprolol. We conclude that both drugs are effective in the prevention of migraine attacks but a higher number of dropouts occurred on flunarizine because of depression or weight gain.
在一项针对149例有或无先兆偏头痛患者的多中心随机双盲试验中,研究了氟桂利嗪和美托洛尔的预防效果。在为期4周的安慰剂导入期后,患者被随机分配接受每日10毫克氟桂利嗪或每日200毫克美托洛尔治疗16周(平行组设计)。与安慰剂导入期相比,两种药物均使每月偏头痛天数减少了37%(95%置信区间21 - 53%)。两种药物均显著降低了所有疗效参数,且在治疗期间的任何时间,两种药物之间均未发现显著差异。然而,95%置信区间的计算表明,每种药物在单个主要效应参数上可能具有超过100%的优势。最常见的不良经历是日间镇静(两种药物均有)和体重增加(氟桂利嗪)。抑郁是最严重的副作用,氟桂利嗪组发生率为8%,美托洛尔组为3%。我们得出结论,两种药物在预防偏头痛发作方面均有效,但由于抑郁或体重增加,氟桂利嗪组的退出人数较多。