Lin Pao-Hwa, Appel Lawrence J, Funk Kristine, Craddick Shirley, Chen Chuhe, Elmer Patricia, McBurnie Mary Ann, Champagne Catherine
Department of Medicine, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710, USA.
J Am Diet Assoc. 2007 Sep;107(9):1541-51. doi: 10.1016/j.jada.2007.06.019.
To examine the influence of the PREMIER study lifestyle interventions on dietary intakes and adherence to the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) dietary pattern and the Dietary Reference Intakes (DRI).
An 18-month multicenter, randomized controlled trial comparing two multicomponent lifestyle intervention programs to an advice only control group.
SUBJECTS/SETTING: A total of 810 participants were recruited from local communities and randomized into the study. Individuals were eligible if they were aged 25 years or older, had body mass index between 18.5 and 45.0, not taking antihypertensive medication, and had prehypertension or stage 1 hypertension (systolic blood pressure 120 to 159 mm Hg and diastolic blood pressure 80 to 95 mm Hg).
The two active intervention programs were a behavioral lifestyle intervention that implements established recommendations, and an established intervention plus the DASH dietary pattern. Both interventions consisted of intensive group and individual counseling sessions. The control group received a brief advice session after randomization and again after 6 months of data collection. Dietary intakes were collected by two random 24-hour recalls at baseline, 6 months, and 18 months.
The primary outcome of the PREMIER study was change in systolic blood pressure at 6 months. The main outcomes examined here include dietary variables collected by 24-hour recall at each time point.
Nutrient intakes were calculated and compared among the time points and the three intervention groups using mixed models with repeated measures at 6 and 18 months. Proportion of participants who met or achieved the original DASH nutrient intake levels and the DRIs were calculated and compared among the three intervention groups. P<0.01 was considered statistically significant.
Participants in both the established intervention and established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern groups substantially reduced energy, total fat, saturated fat, and sodium intake and these reductions persisted throughout the study. Established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern group participants increased intakes of fruits, vegetables, dairy, and many vitamins and minerals; these increases were significantly greater than that of the control and established intervention groups. A majority of established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern group participants achieved at least two thirds of the DRI recommendations for most nutrients at 6 months, despite their reduction in total energy intake. Some but relatively small recidivism occurred at 18 months.
Both the established intervention and established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern group intervention were effective in helping participants follow established recommendations to control blood pressure. The advice-only control group also made some behavior changes, mainly decreasing energy and sodium intake. Only the established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern group significantly increased intakes of DASH-specific food groups, including fruits, vegetables, and dairy products, and nutrients, including protein, fiber, calcium, potassium, and magnesium. Most of the increases did not reach the levels consumed in the original DASH feeding studies. Whereas the established intervention plus DASH dietary pattern group intervention provides a useful platform to achieve the DASH dietary pattern and current DRI recommendations, intervention enhancements, including a greater emphasis on nutrient-dense foods, would likely improve this intervention.
研究“首优”研究中的生活方式干预对饮食摄入量以及遵循终止高血压膳食方法(DASH)饮食模式和膳食参考摄入量(DRI)的影响。
一项为期18个月的多中心随机对照试验,将两个多成分生活方式干预项目与一个仅提供建议的对照组进行比较。
受试者/研究地点:从当地社区招募了810名参与者并随机分组进入研究。年龄在25岁及以上、体重指数在18.5至45.0之间、未服用抗高血压药物且患有高血压前期或1期高血压(收缩压120至159毫米汞柱,舒张压80至95毫米汞柱)的个体符合入选条件。
两个积极干预项目分别是实施既定建议的行为生活方式干预,以及既定干预加上DASH饮食模式。两种干预均包括强化的小组和个体咨询课程。对照组在随机分组后以及数据收集6个月后各接受一次简短的建议课程。在基线、6个月和18个月时通过两次随机的24小时饮食回顾来收集饮食摄入量。
“首优”研究的主要结局是6个月时收缩压的变化。此处研究的主要结局包括在每个时间点通过24小时饮食回顾收集的饮食变量。
使用混合模型并在6个月和18个月时进行重复测量,计算并比较各时间点以及三个干预组之间的营养素摄入量。计算并比较三个干预组中达到或实现原始DASH营养素摄入水平和DRI的参与者比例。P<0.01被认为具有统计学意义。
既定干预组和既定干预加DASH饮食模式组的参与者均大幅降低了能量、总脂肪、饱和脂肪和钠的摄入量,并且这些减少在整个研究过程中持续存在。既定干预加DASH饮食模式组的参与者增加了水果、蔬菜、乳制品以及多种维生素和矿物质的摄入量;这些增加显著大于对照组和既定干预组。尽管总能量摄入减少,但既定干预加DASH饮食模式组的大多数参与者在6个月时至少达到了大多数营养素DRI建议量的三分之二。在18个月时出现了一些但相对较少的复发情况。
既定干预组和既定干预加DASH饮食模式组的干预在帮助参与者遵循既定建议控制血压方面均有效。仅提供建议的对照组也有一些行为改变,主要是减少了能量和钠的摄入量。只有既定干预加DASH饮食模式组显著增加了特定DASH食物组(包括水果、蔬菜和乳制品)以及营养素(包括蛋白质、纤维、钙、钾和镁)的摄入量。大多数增加未达到原始DASH喂养研究中的摄入水平。虽然既定干预加DASH饮食模式组的干预为实现DASH饮食模式和当前DRI建议提供了一个有用的平台,但包括更加强调营养丰富食物在内的干预强化措施可能会改善这种干预效果。